Reply the solution through email......!!!!
-
Quote:
what happens if you email someone and that post appears,
No, Email should not be converted into the post. Only reply for the post should be submitted on that thread. Scenario: 1) I got one Question through RSS feeds, I reply from email client and it submit it as a solution(if it enclose with <Solution> element. if it posted with <comment> tag then it should be post as comment. 2) if i got email comment on particular solution, it will definitly post as comment for the reply from email client. Does it make scence ?
Thanks -Amit Gajjar (MinterProject)
@amitgajjar wrote:
Does it make scence ?
I see. So, you want replies that go through CP servers to be converted based on an arbitrary set of rules. What do you do with replies that somebody misspells comment, for instance?
*pre-emptive celebratory nipple tassle jiggle* - Sean Ewington
"Mind bleach! Send me mind bleach!" - Nagy Vilmos
CodeStash - Online Snippet Management | My blog | MoXAML PowerToys | Mole 2010 - debugging made easier
-
@amitgajjar wrote:
Does it make scence ?
I see. So, you want replies that go through CP servers to be converted based on an arbitrary set of rules. What do you do with replies that somebody misspells comment, for instance?
*pre-emptive celebratory nipple tassle jiggle* - Sean Ewington
"Mind bleach! Send me mind bleach!" - Nagy Vilmos
CodeStash - Online Snippet Management | My blog | MoXAML PowerToys | Mole 2010 - debugging made easier
In this scenario we need to use Subject as Primary information. User do not need to modify subject line and CP server will parse it and process accordingly.
Quote:
somebody misspells comment
By default any of the reply would be converted as comment. Even that is not required. if we restrict people to post only single solution for any question. but i don't think it's good option. Anyway the answer is default message will be posted as Comment. As far as discussion section is concern we can use this without any issue. Except the category of the reply (i.e. Genera, Question, Answer...etc.) But this will be easier to reply more threads then ever we have imagine.
Thanks -Amit Gajjar (MinterProject)
-
In this scenario we need to use Subject as Primary information. User do not need to modify subject line and CP server will parse it and process accordingly.
Quote:
somebody misspells comment
By default any of the reply would be converted as comment. Even that is not required. if we restrict people to post only single solution for any question. but i don't think it's good option. Anyway the answer is default message will be posted as Comment. As far as discussion section is concern we can use this without any issue. Except the category of the reply (i.e. Genera, Question, Answer...etc.) But this will be easier to reply more threads then ever we have imagine.
Thanks -Amit Gajjar (MinterProject)
In my opinion, we should just stick with the mechanisms we've got. If someone needs to reply, they really should do it through CP.
*pre-emptive celebratory nipple tassle jiggle* - Sean Ewington
"Mind bleach! Send me mind bleach!" - Nagy Vilmos
CodeStash - Online Snippet Management | My blog | MoXAML PowerToys | Mole 2010 - debugging made easier
-
In my opinion, we should just stick with the mechanisms we've got. If someone needs to reply, they really should do it through CP.
*pre-emptive celebratory nipple tassle jiggle* - Sean Ewington
"Mind bleach! Send me mind bleach!" - Nagy Vilmos
CodeStash - Online Snippet Management | My blog | MoXAML PowerToys | Mole 2010 - debugging made easier
I agree, When there is no option we have to stick to that. But this is just suggestion. Thanks for the discussion :thumbsup:
Thanks -Amit Gajjar (MinterProject)
-
Hi, Could it be possible now or in future to reply for any comment through registered email will post in particular discussion ? Say, i got one comment in one article and when i do reply(from email) it should be post on that comment. And do we have RSS feed for QA ? it would be nice to have email reply feature from QA. People can post solution from email.
Thanks -Amit Gajjar (MinterProject)
Your interaction with other members is valuable to the whole community, not just you. The discussion/replies could help other developers.
-
Your interaction with other members is valuable to the whole community, not just you. The discussion/replies could help other developers.
Yes ofcourse. that's why this suggestion is to post discussion in CP when any contributor reply the discussion through email client.
Thanks -Amit Gajjar (MinterProject)
-
Yes ofcourse. that's why this suggestion is to post discussion in CP when any contributor reply the discussion through email client.
Thanks -Amit Gajjar (MinterProject)
If you want the community to see your discussion, then you should not have the discussion via email.
-
If you want the community to see your discussion, then you should not have the discussion via email.
Let me explain, When you got email that someone have replied on your article, you can use reply button to post your message on code project. it will append that message in that discussion in codeproject. So, Yes community people can view your discussion as it will be posted via email.
Thanks -Amit Gajjar (MinterProject)
-
Let me explain, When you got email that someone have replied on your article, you can use reply button to post your message on code project. it will append that message in that discussion in codeproject. So, Yes community people can view your discussion as it will be posted via email.
Thanks -Amit Gajjar (MinterProject)
Let me explain... Just have your discussion via the website and skip the added complexity of the email feature. My opinion. :)
-
Let me explain... Just have your discussion via the website and skip the added complexity of the email feature. My opinion. :)
:-D Right, This idea comes in my head so just want to share. And nothing wrong in discussing new ideas. am i right ?
Thanks -Amit Gajjar (MinterProject)
-
:-D Right, This idea comes in my head so just want to share. And nothing wrong in discussing new ideas. am i right ?
Thanks -Amit Gajjar (MinterProject)
@amitgajjar wrote:
nothing wrong in discussing new ideas. am i right ?
Correct. However, it is my perception, that Chris and company, only make changes on the site if they feel that it will benefit the masses and not the few. Your idea, IMHO, is for the few and not the masses. It's a good idea. -- Cheers.