Time to go?
-
Jason Henderson wrote: If the need were great and I was drafted, I would go willingly. What your argument need is Logic, Logic, and more Logic: If you are drafted to go, then you are not doing so willingly.
You are trying to impose a logical response on an emotional issue. That is not how it works. Besides, there are ways around the draft so what he says is not quite as contradictory as it reads. He may have meant 'If I know I'm about to be drafted I'll go volunteer'. Many men did this in WWII and Veitnam. If you volunteer you are more likely to get your choice of posting or trade within the forces.
-
I'm ready to volunteer and I'm not even American. Sooner or later you'll all realise that the only way you can keep any vestige of the freedoms you take for granted is to fight for them. And whether or not you agree with the way Bush/Blair have handled things eventually we'll have to acknowledge that the war needs to be fought and won, decisively. Remember, the price of freedom is, most often, war. Mark, London.
You can't get the spastic knee-jerk whiners to understand things no matter how hard you try. Just rest easy in the knowledge that if Kerry had done the exact same thing then those now rending their clothes and whining like little bitches would be the ones supporting it. It is funny and sad at the same time.
Glano perictu com sahni delorin!
-
No, I think you may have side swiped the point. It seems there was just no real point in trying to 'save' the Iraqis when they'll simply revert to type once we leave. Of course, we could just dump a large cache of weapons in the desert, pull out and see what happens. I see no point in our boys getting killed and maimed when the end result will be that it'll collapse back to its previous state. Bit like trying to hold back entropy - can't be done. On the other hand if we went after the real enemies more vigorously... maybe with a nuke or 3...
Anonymous wrote: No, I think you may have side swiped the point. On the contrary, you are not addressing my point. You say we must fight for Iraqi's freedom. I say no we don't. Now you say... Anonymous wrote: It seems there was just no real point in trying to 'save' the Iraqis when they'll simply revert to type once we leave. So what in the world are you trying to say?:confused::~ Later, JoeSox "What I like to drink most is wine that belongs to others." -- Diogenes Laërtius joeswammi.com ↔ humanaiproject.org ↔ joeswammi.com/sinfest
-
Jason Henderson wrote: I support the war, but I don't want to go fight if I'm not needed. That's why we have a standing army. If the need were great and I was drafted, I would go willingly. The thing about warfare is that it's become increasingly technical and highly skilled over the last 100 years. 100 years ago you didn't have fighter jets or tanks, you barely had machine guns. Wars now don't need millions of men sitting in trenches and charging at the other side, hoping they don't get blown up in the process. A military draft now would almost be counterproductive, because you don't want millions of poorly trained soldiers in tin helmets carrying rifles with bayonets, you want a (few) hundred thousand really well trained ones with good equipment and superior firepower. Which is what modern militaries are. Do you really want a codeproject members light brigade? :-)
Ian Darling "If we've learned anything from history, it's that those who feed trolls are condemned to repetitive conversations. Or something like that." - Eric Lippert
Ian Darling wrote: Do you really want a codeproject members light brigade? Half a post, half a post, Half a post onward, All in the Valley of Soapbox rants Rode the One Million. "Forward, the CP brigade!" "Argue with no logic!" he said: Into the Valley of Soapbox rants Rode the One Million
Jeremy Kimball magnae clunes mihi placent, nec possum de hac re mentiri. (Large buttocks are pleasing to me, nor am I able to lie concerning this matter)
-
You can't get the spastic knee-jerk whiners to understand things no matter how hard you try. Just rest easy in the knowledge that if Kerry had done the exact same thing then those now rending their clothes and whining like little bitches would be the ones supporting it. It is funny and sad at the same time.
Glano perictu com sahni delorin!
"Spastic". There's an insult I haven't heard since the school playground. No, really! ;) ;)
-
Jason Henderson wrote: If the need were great and I was drafted, I would go willingly. What your argument need is Logic, Logic, and more Logic: If you are drafted to go, then you are not doing so willingly.
Anonymously wrote: What your argument need is Logic, Logic, and more Logic: If you are drafted to go, then you are not doing so willingly. I won't run off to Canada or try to call my self a conciensious objector (however its spelled). If I'm needed, I'll go.
"We have done so much in the last 2 years, and it doesn't happen by standing around with your finger in your ear, hoping everyone thinks that that's nice." - Donald Rumsfeld
Jason Henderson
blog -
"Spastic". There's an insult I haven't heard since the school playground. No, really! ;) ;)
Robert Edward Caldecott wrote: "Spastic". There's an insult I haven't heard since the school playground. No, really! THen you obviously haven't been hanging around at my place :)
Glano perictu com sahni delorin!
-
You can't get the spastic knee-jerk whiners to understand things no matter how hard you try. Just rest easy in the knowledge that if Kerry had done the exact same thing then those now rending their clothes and whining like little bitches would be the ones supporting it. It is funny and sad at the same time.
Glano perictu com sahni delorin!
-
A: So one can safely assume that you stay as far away from the freedoms that the west offers its citizens as you your little legs can carry you? B: You've been there, tried it and then decided you didn't like it. C: I'm utterly wrong and you were simply trying to be quaintly ironic. D: There is no D. BTW as a child/teenager I also held lofty but largely pompous ideals about life and my place in it, etc, etc. As a parent I would willingly lay down my life for my children and for their safety and freedom. I would not hesitate to volunteer if called upon to do so even if it meant sitting behind a desk to free up a foot soldier to defend our freedoms and to ensure future peace and prosperity for my children. Mark, London
Anonymous wrote: So one can safely assume that you stay as far away from the freedoms Binarity of thoughts. Grade F. Dismissed. B comes closes. It isn't really that I don't like it, but it'de definitely way overrated.
Flirt harder, I'm a Coder
mlog || Agile Programming | doxygen -
No, I think you may have side swiped the point. It seems there was just no real point in trying to 'save' the Iraqis when they'll simply revert to type once we leave. Of course, we could just dump a large cache of weapons in the desert, pull out and see what happens. I see no point in our boys getting killed and maimed when the end result will be that it'll collapse back to its previous state. Bit like trying to hold back entropy - can't be done. On the other hand if we went after the real enemies more vigorously... maybe with a nuke or 3...
-
Sorry - "scoper". S C O P E R. Scoper. Scope scope scope. Nope. It just doesn't have the same fricitive qualities.
Glano perictu com sahni delorin!