Unable to approve an article/technical blog
-
Maybe a popup that says "N more approvals needed for publication."
Best wishes, Hans
-
By current trends yes, I do think the number is too big. But we're getting the word out. The Lounge knows, and now Site Bugs / Suggestions is catching moderation fever. Next week we'll do a newsletter mention, and see if that rallies the community. Don't worry, I won't let blog entries and tips & tricks flounder too long. Big Hamster is watching.
Thanks, Sean Ewington The Code Project
Sean, This is a very good initiative. :thumbsup: But I would say this workflow needs to be redesign based on the membership level / Reputation Points of Authors . Author who has certain number of article and enough Author Reputation why they do needs this filter ? Assume, Sacha posted an killer article and he also needs to wait for 5 person to review and approve his article. :sigh: Coming back to Technical Blog post, If the post is feeded from blog which has already been received from Code Project Associate blog then why these numbers of approval level ? It was Just my thoughts !
Cheers ! Abhijit Jana | My Blog | @Twitter | Daily .Net Tips
-
I don't like the idea of a popup, but perhaps the text should be shown next to the approve button and updated when its clicked.
3x12=36 2x12=24 1x12=12 0x12=18
Dan Neely wrote:
I don't like the idea of a popup
Whatever.... they will decide the proper way but that's a good suggestion. Also, this should be visible to the authors saying that "x of y approvals pending"... What do you say? BTW, I am not happy with the current approval system. :(
Regards - Kunal Chowdhury | Microsoft MVP (Silverlight) | CodeProject MVP | Software Engineer
My Latest Article [14-Mar-2011]: Step by Step to discuss Application Library Caching in Silverlight 4
-
Maybe a popup that says "N more approvals needed for publication."
Best wishes, Hans
Hans, any opinion on this ?[^]
Cheers ! Abhijit Jana | My Blog | @Twitter | Daily .Net Tips
-
Sean, This is a very good initiative. :thumbsup: But I would say this workflow needs to be redesign based on the membership level / Reputation Points of Authors . Author who has certain number of article and enough Author Reputation why they do needs this filter ? Assume, Sacha posted an killer article and he also needs to wait for 5 person to review and approve his article. :sigh: Coming back to Technical Blog post, If the post is feeded from blog which has already been received from Code Project Associate blog then why these numbers of approval level ? It was Just my thoughts !
Cheers ! Abhijit Jana | My Blog | @Twitter | Daily .Net Tips
Abhijit Jana wrote:
Sacha posted an killer article and he also needs to wait for 5 person to review and approve his article.
:rolleyes:
Abhijit Jana wrote:
Author who has certain number of article and enough Author Reputation why they do needs this filter ?
:thumbsup:
Abhijit Jana wrote:
If the post is feeded from blog which has already been received from Code Project Associate blog then why these numbers of approval level ?
:thumbsup:
Regards - Kunal Chowdhury | Microsoft MVP (Silverlight) | CodeProject MVP | Software Engineer
My Latest Article [14-Mar-2011]: Step by Step to discuss Application Library Caching in Silverlight 4
-
Sean, This is a very good initiative. :thumbsup: But I would say this workflow needs to be redesign based on the membership level / Reputation Points of Authors . Author who has certain number of article and enough Author Reputation why they do needs this filter ? Assume, Sacha posted an killer article and he also needs to wait for 5 person to review and approve his article. :sigh: Coming back to Technical Blog post, If the post is feeded from blog which has already been received from Code Project Associate blog then why these numbers of approval level ? It was Just my thoughts !
Cheers ! Abhijit Jana | My Blog | @Twitter | Daily .Net Tips
You really think it will take long for 5 silver or above members to approve an article from Sacha?
cheers, Chris Maunder The Code Project | Co-founder Microsoft C++ MVP
-
Oh, that's a new feature then. I am not aware of this recent change. :doh: I was :zzz: for some days.
Regards - Kunal Chowdhury | Microsoft MVP (Silverlight) | CodeProject MVP | Software Engineer
My Latest Article [14-Mar-2011]: Step by Step to discuss Application Library Caching in Silverlight 4
Does no one read[^] Where would be the best place to announce these things? A CodeProject blog? My blog? Big announcement boxes on the homepage?
cheers, Chris Maunder The Code Project | Co-founder Microsoft C++ MVP
-
Does no one read[^] Where would be the best place to announce these things? A CodeProject blog? My blog? Big announcement boxes on the homepage?
cheers, Chris Maunder The Code Project | Co-founder Microsoft C++ MVP
-
You really think it will take long for 5 silver or above members to approve an article from Sacha?
cheers, Chris Maunder The Code Project | Co-founder Microsoft C++ MVP
Good Day Chris. Sacha was just an example. My thought was to put some Reputation points along with the approval workflow. :)
Chris Maunder wrote:
5 silver or above members to approve
Then why not increasing the moderator level. like only 2 Platinum member ? And for Tech blog, if the Author is Platinum, any one platinum apart from the author ?
Cheers ! Abhijit Jana | My Blog | @Twitter | Daily .Net Tips
-
Does no one read[^] Where would be the best place to announce these things? A CodeProject blog? My blog? Big announcement boxes on the homepage?
cheers, Chris Maunder The Code Project | Co-founder Microsoft C++ MVP
Chris Maunder wrote:
Few do miss... spare rest all of us, who did read it. :)
Sandeep Mewara [My latest tip/trick] [Forum guidelines]
-
Good Day Chris. Sacha was just an example. My thought was to put some Reputation points along with the approval workflow. :)
Chris Maunder wrote:
5 silver or above members to approve
Then why not increasing the moderator level. like only 2 Platinum member ? And for Tech blog, if the Author is Platinum, any one platinum apart from the author ?
Cheers ! Abhijit Jana | My Blog | @Twitter | Daily .Net Tips
Abhijit Jana wrote:
Then why not increasing the moderator level. like only 2 Platinum member ?
We've had platinum (gold?) members go on univoting spree's in the lounge; what makes you think they're not capable of idiot approval for articles as well?
3x12=36 2x12=24 1x12=12 0x12=18
-
Abhijit Jana wrote:
Then why not increasing the moderator level. like only 2 Platinum member ?
We've had platinum (gold?) members go on univoting spree's in the lounge; what makes you think they're not capable of idiot approval for articles as well?
3x12=36 2x12=24 1x12=12 0x12=18
Dan Neely wrote:
what makes you think they're not capable of idiot approval for articles as well?
Dan, I was not talking about the capability at anywhere and not that was my intention. My suggestion was, while setting multiple level of approval for an, taking consideration of Reputation point.
Cheers ! Abhijit Jana | My Blog | @Twitter | Daily .Net Tips
-
Good Day Chris. Sacha was just an example. My thought was to put some Reputation points along with the approval workflow. :)
Chris Maunder wrote:
5 silver or above members to approve
Then why not increasing the moderator level. like only 2 Platinum member ? And for Tech blog, if the Author is Platinum, any one platinum apart from the author ?
Cheers ! Abhijit Jana | My Blog | @Twitter | Daily .Net Tips
We have thousands of silver (and above) members. I prefer to have a decent number of members approve (or remove) articles than just one or two, and it should be a non-issue once more members start reporting and approving articles.
cheers, Chris Maunder The Code Project | Co-founder Microsoft C++ MVP