pi
-
I'm trying to find a good way to explain why pi is infinite (not what it is). And I'm drawing up blanks. Any math gurus care to shed me some light please? Jeremy Falcon
-
I'm trying to find a good way to explain why pi is infinite (not what it is). And I'm drawing up blanks. Any math gurus care to shed me some light please? Jeremy Falcon
It's not infinite. It's irrational[^]. It can be cranky too if you're not careful. cheers, Chris Maunder
CodeProject.com : C++ MVP
-
It's not infinite. It's irrational[^]. It can be cranky too if you're not careful. cheers, Chris Maunder
CodeProject.com : C++ MVP
I thought you could still have an infinite irrational number though. Or, is that not the case? Jeremy Falcon
-
I'm trying to find a good way to explain why pi is infinite (not what it is). And I'm drawing up blanks. Any math gurus care to shed me some light please? Jeremy Falcon
Pi is an irrational number. It cannot be written as P/Q, where P and Q are integers. All irrational numbers have the property that they are infinitely long, otherwise it would be possible to write them as P/Q and thus be a rational number. Irrational Number => Infinite Length. The converse of the above state is not necessarily true. For example 1/3 is rational, yet it is written as 0.3333333... -Sean ---- Shag a Lizard
-
Pi is an irrational number. It cannot be written as P/Q, where P and Q are integers. All irrational numbers have the property that they are infinitely long, otherwise it would be possible to write them as P/Q and thus be a rational number. Irrational Number => Infinite Length. The converse of the above state is not necessarily true. For example 1/3 is rational, yet it is written as 0.3333333... -Sean ---- Shag a Lizard
Sean Cundiff wrote:
All irrational numbers have the property that they are infinitely long, otherwise it would be possible to write them as P/Q and thus be a rational number.
Ok that makes sense. Given what you and Chris said, I suppose the idea I'm trying to understand then is why is Pi an irrational number? What makes it go on forever? And yeah, I'm trying to improve my math skills, so bear with me. :-O Jeremy Falcon
-
Sean Cundiff wrote:
All irrational numbers have the property that they are infinitely long, otherwise it would be possible to write them as P/Q and thus be a rational number.
Ok that makes sense. Given what you and Chris said, I suppose the idea I'm trying to understand then is why is Pi an irrational number? What makes it go on forever? And yeah, I'm trying to improve my math skills, so bear with me. :-O Jeremy Falcon
1 / 3 is infinite too ! Any number that cannot be write an integer / 10 ^ some power is infinite. what are you trying to understand? It's also irrational, as pointed out. Could you explain your exact problem? That would help us give you a good solution! ;P
-
1 / 3 is infinite too ! Any number that cannot be write an integer / 10 ^ some power is infinite. what are you trying to understand? It's also irrational, as pointed out. Could you explain your exact problem? That would help us give you a good solution! ;P
Super Lloyd wrote:
Could you explain your exact problem? That would help us give you a good solution!
I did. I asked why is Pi infinite. I understand what you said, but that still doesn't address why it is like that - it just reaffirms it's infinite. I'm trying to really understand Pi outside a textbook definition I reckon. Jeremy Falcon
-
Sean Cundiff wrote:
All irrational numbers have the property that they are infinitely long, otherwise it would be possible to write them as P/Q and thus be a rational number.
Ok that makes sense. Given what you and Chris said, I suppose the idea I'm trying to understand then is why is Pi an irrational number? What makes it go on forever? And yeah, I'm trying to improve my math skills, so bear with me. :-O Jeremy Falcon
Jeremy Falcon wrote:
Given what you and Chris said, I suppose the idea I'm trying to understand then is why is Pi an irrational number? What makes it go on forever?
Because pi <> P/Q ;P Seriously, if you can answer why some of the most important numbers known to man are irrational (e, pi, h_bar, etc) you will be a god among insects. -Sean ---- Shag a Lizard
-
Jeremy Falcon wrote:
Given what you and Chris said, I suppose the idea I'm trying to understand then is why is Pi an irrational number? What makes it go on forever?
Because pi <> P/Q ;P Seriously, if you can answer why some of the most important numbers known to man are irrational (e, pi, h_bar, etc) you will be a god among insects. -Sean ---- Shag a Lizard
Sean Cundiff wrote:
Seriously, if you can answer why some of the most important numbers known to man are irrational (e, pi, h_bar, etc) you will be a god among insects.
It's going to drive me crazy if it never "clicks". Time for my medication now! Breathe. Breathe Jeremy! :-D Jeremy Falcon
-
Sean Cundiff wrote:
Seriously, if you can answer why some of the most important numbers known to man are irrational (e, pi, h_bar, etc) you will be a god among insects.
It's going to drive me crazy if it never "clicks". Time for my medication now! Breathe. Breathe Jeremy! :-D Jeremy Falcon
Think of it this way: pi = circumference of a circle / diameter of the circle. There is no way to set the circumference to a rational quantity while at the same time keeping the diameter a rational quantity. pi = rational/irrational or irrational/rational. Why such a fundamental thing as a circle exhibits this quantity property is a matter of philosophical debate. -Sean ---- Shag a Lizard -- modified at 22:06 Thursday 16th March, 2006
-
Sean Cundiff wrote:
Seriously, if you can answer why some of the most important numbers known to man are irrational (e, pi, h_bar, etc) you will be a god among insects.
It's going to drive me crazy if it never "clicks". Time for my medication now! Breathe. Breathe Jeremy! :-D Jeremy Falcon
When the meds have kicked in take a look at transcendental numbers[^]. Pi's not only irrational, it's also transcendental. cheers, Chris Maunder
CodeProject.com : C++ MVP
-
Sean Cundiff wrote:
Seriously, if you can answer why some of the most important numbers known to man are irrational (e, pi, h_bar, etc) you will be a god among insects.
It's going to drive me crazy if it never "clicks". Time for my medication now! Breathe. Breathe Jeremy! :-D Jeremy Falcon
Work the proof for PI you might find that is exactly what you need. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pi[^]
A Plain English signature. Code-frog System Architects, Inc.
-
Super Lloyd wrote:
Could you explain your exact problem? That would help us give you a good solution!
I did. I asked why is Pi infinite. I understand what you said, but that still doesn't address why it is like that - it just reaffirms it's infinite. I'm trying to really understand Pi outside a textbook definition I reckon. Jeremy Falcon
it's not infinite, it's 3.14159265.... infinite is much bigger than that! ;P do you mean never repeat? 1st I believe you could have never repeating rationale (integer / integer) as well, this is simply an artefact of decimal notation. 2nd: yes PI is very special, it's a not even a real such as SQRT(2). Real number (as opposed to rational and integer) are solutino to polynomes equation (e.g. x^2 = 2) No Polynome with real parammters has PI has its solution. (same for 'e' (i.e. 2.7182818...)) they solve an other class of problem altogether...
-
Super Lloyd wrote:
Could you explain your exact problem? That would help us give you a good solution!
I did. I asked why is Pi infinite. I understand what you said, but that still doesn't address why it is like that - it just reaffirms it's infinite. I'm trying to really understand Pi outside a textbook definition I reckon. Jeremy Falcon
BTW, if PI repeated, it could expressed as a rational, hence it can't be!
-
Think of it this way: pi = circumference of a circle / diameter of the circle. There is no way to set the circumference to a rational quantity while at the same time keeping the diameter a rational quantity. pi = rational/irrational or irrational/rational. Why such a fundamental thing as a circle exhibits this quantity property is a matter of philosophical debate. -Sean ---- Shag a Lizard -- modified at 22:06 Thursday 16th March, 2006
Sean Cundiff wrote:
Why such a fundamental thing as a circle exhibits this quantity property is a matter of philosophical debate.
You just beat me to my question. Jeremy Falcon
-
Work the proof for PI you might find that is exactly what you need. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pi[^]
A Plain English signature. Code-frog System Architects, Inc.
It still didn't address the why. If it did, I didn't understand it. :) Jeremy Falcon
-
When the meds have kicked in take a look at transcendental numbers[^]. Pi's not only irrational, it's also transcendental. cheers, Chris Maunder
CodeProject.com : C++ MVP
Chris Maunder wrote:
Pi's not only irrational, it's also transcendental.
:doh: Back to the books for me. :laugh: Jeremy Falcon
-
it's not infinite, it's 3.14159265.... infinite is much bigger than that! ;P do you mean never repeat? 1st I believe you could have never repeating rationale (integer / integer) as well, this is simply an artefact of decimal notation. 2nd: yes PI is very special, it's a not even a real such as SQRT(2). Real number (as opposed to rational and integer) are solutino to polynomes equation (e.g. x^2 = 2) No Polynome with real parammters has PI has its solution. (same for 'e' (i.e. 2.7182818...)) they solve an other class of problem altogether...
Super Lloyd wrote:
do you mean never repeat?
I was under the impression it was infinite, just as 1/3 would also be. Jeremy Falcon
-
it's not infinite, it's 3.14159265.... infinite is much bigger than that! ;P do you mean never repeat? 1st I believe you could have never repeating rationale (integer / integer) as well, this is simply an artefact of decimal notation. 2nd: yes PI is very special, it's a not even a real such as SQRT(2). Real number (as opposed to rational and integer) are solutino to polynomes equation (e.g. x^2 = 2) No Polynome with real parammters has PI has its solution. (same for 'e' (i.e. 2.7182818...)) they solve an other class of problem altogether...
Super Lloyd wrote:
PI is very special, it's a not even a real such as SQRT(2).
What do you mean? :wtf: Of course PI is a real number! The definition of a real number is that it's square should be nonnegative. And PI * PI is nonnegative. Cheers, Vikram.
I don't know and you don't either. Militant Agnostic
-
Super Lloyd wrote:
PI is very special, it's a not even a real such as SQRT(2).
What do you mean? :wtf: Of course PI is a real number! The definition of a real number is that it's square should be nonnegative. And PI * PI is nonnegative. Cheers, Vikram.
I don't know and you don't either. Militant Agnostic
As Chris Munder said, it's a Transcendental number[^], much more uncommon than mere real number.