Ladder Logic any experts here?
-
Hi Glen, I can't find a real question from you - no matter ... I would say that I'm very familiar especially with Siemens-PLC's - I'm working with it the last 35 years ... so if I could help you ...? Independant : there is a very good PLC-Forum in Germany (www.SPS-Forum.de) where you can ask questions (normally in German but English is also possible) which I would recommend to you ...
Hi, Sorry about that don't really have any questions yet, before I open the box I kinda like to know I have access to someone who might know enough to help me shut the box. A pre-emptive cry for help if you like. There are issues that need sorting that aren't directly software linked (like a sensor going into error constantly, the patch cable had come out!). I was more after someone I could ask if my Ladder Logic was correct. It seems from the way it's set up, it won't need as much alteration as I thought. One line going a speed when called via a push button, another line going the opposite way when called by a button and a roller table non-powered between them. At the moment it looks like we can just flatten the square and go from there with no alteration (until the ammount of room is changed so we either need to lengthen it or shorten it) Thanks Glenn :-D
-
Hi, Sorry about that don't really have any questions yet, before I open the box I kinda like to know I have access to someone who might know enough to help me shut the box. A pre-emptive cry for help if you like. There are issues that need sorting that aren't directly software linked (like a sensor going into error constantly, the patch cable had come out!). I was more after someone I could ask if my Ladder Logic was correct. It seems from the way it's set up, it won't need as much alteration as I thought. One line going a speed when called via a push button, another line going the opposite way when called by a button and a roller table non-powered between them. At the moment it looks like we can just flatten the square and go from there with no alteration (until the ammount of room is changed so we either need to lengthen it or shorten it) Thanks Glenn :-D
So let's make it short ... if you have any specific questions feel free to ask me - or do it inside the Forum I suggested to you (where I am one of the Moderators). Independant - I'm quite sure that you could be helped to solve your issue ... but for that it's necessary to habe the relevant source-code. But some question from me : - which kind of Siemens-SW are you using ? - is that code written in Step7-Classic or TIA ? - do you know that normally you could switch from Ladder (KOP) to Instructions-List (AWL - sorry I only know the German words) or Function-Plan (FUP)
-
So let's make it short ... if you have any specific questions feel free to ask me - or do it inside the Forum I suggested to you (where I am one of the Moderators). Independant - I'm quite sure that you could be helped to solve your issue ... but for that it's necessary to habe the relevant source-code. But some question from me : - which kind of Siemens-SW are you using ? - is that code written in Step7-Classic or TIA ? - do you know that normally you could switch from Ladder (KOP) to Instructions-List (AWL - sorry I only know the German words) or Function-Plan (FUP)
I think we are using TIA version 17... if that makes sense, the ladder appears inside funtion blocks (which confused me!) I will get over to the Forum you suggested, I know the registering process can take a little time. The source code is a collection of three files (does that sound right?). I'm having to pick up a project that got part done, then Covid happened and the guilty party (person that had all the knowledge) left!
-
Hi All, I have been given the task (read 'saddle with') of reverse engineering and modifying a Siemens conveyor system. The thing uses a version of Ladder Logic (if you don't know it's a Programming system that was designed to be easy to read, I think we all know what that creates). I used a simple form Allen-Bradley form back at college (many moons ago!) I appear to have lost all reference I had for it. The situation is the system works, I don't want to risk breaking it. So if anyone has a reference it would be very nice! Glenn
I can help you out with that, Glenn. I am maybe not as good as Ralf aobve, but I am pretty good too. Give me a PM here and I will answer you per mail, where we can continue writing or arrange a live conversation
M.D.V. ;) If something has a solution... Why do we have to worry about?. If it has no solution... For what reason do we have to worry about? Help me to understand what I'm saying, and I'll explain it better to you Rating helpful answers is nice, but saying thanks can be even nicer.
-
Glenn, The latest Siemens PLC development tool is called TIA (Totally Integrated Automation). It is a free download and has a 14 day demo license. It also includes full help files. I think its at v17 or v18. If you don't find what you need elsewhere, this might be an avenue to get there. BTW: Previous to TIA they used Step 7 (v5.x) and it had the same free d/l, demo and help system concept. It might be more appropriate if you're dealing with "old" logic. Not sure if its still available from Siemens.
v17.x.x
fgs1963 wrote:
It also includes full help files.
And they actually are not that bad.
fgs1963 wrote:
It might be more appropriate if you're dealing with "old" logic.
Not only might, should. There are "breaking" changes in some important libraries
M.D.V. ;) If something has a solution... Why do we have to worry about?. If it has no solution... For what reason do we have to worry about? Help me to understand what I'm saying, and I'll explain it better to you Rating helpful answers is nice, but saying thanks can be even nicer.
-
Yup - been a Siemens customer for ~25 years. Step 7 from the start and TIA for the last 5 years. As for the Siemens site being a nightmare... 100% agree but its way better than it used to be. X|
Quote:
As for the Siemens site being a nightmare... 100% agree but its way better than it used to be. Dead | X|
Oh dear :bob: worse? :wtf:
-
I can help you out with that, Glenn. I am maybe not as good as Ralf aobve, but I am pretty good too. Give me a PM here and I will answer you per mail, where we can continue writing or arrange a live conversation
M.D.V. ;) If something has a solution... Why do we have to worry about?. If it has no solution... For what reason do we have to worry about? Help me to understand what I'm saying, and I'll explain it better to you Rating helpful answers is nice, but saying thanks can be even nicer.
Hi, Thanks for that, I was having a minor panic attack! I have been billed as an expert, I am not, I have used Allen-Bradley (strangely while I was doing a contract at Siemens). Before that a course at college too long ago. I have access to experts Yayy CP! Glenn
-
Hi, Thanks for that, I was having a minor panic attack! I have been billed as an expert, I am not, I have used Allen-Bradley (strangely while I was doing a contract at Siemens). Before that a course at college too long ago. I have access to experts Yayy CP! Glenn
I even tried a time ago to open a section about it in the forums, articles. But there was not a big resonance and I dropped the idea.
M.D.V. ;) If something has a solution... Why do we have to worry about?. If it has no solution... For what reason do we have to worry about? Help me to understand what I'm saying, and I'll explain it better to you Rating helpful answers is nice, but saying thanks can be even nicer.
-
The Siemens stuff is odd, Siemens web site is very awkward to navigate, you need to login to get access to bits and can be awkward and is generally awkward to use... I point people to it as a "don't do this" example.
-
I think we are using TIA version 17... if that makes sense, the ladder appears inside funtion blocks (which confused me!) I will get over to the Forum you suggested, I know the registering process can take a little time. The source code is a collection of three files (does that sound right?). I'm having to pick up a project that got part done, then Covid happened and the guilty party (person that had all the knowledge) left!
glennPattonWork3 wrote:
the ladder appears inside function blocks (which confused me!)
It's actually pretty cool and very functional (pardon the pun). It's been like this for decades so Siemens was actually ahead of the curve compared to many PLCs. Here are a few basics that might help. OB1 is the "main" cyclic function that loops endlessly. OB100 is a "first scan" function that runs one time at PLC power-on before OB1 starts looping. OB## are interrupt functions that only occur when a fault occurs (hardware or software). FC## are functions with inputs and outputs but no internal storage FB## are functions with inputs, outputs and internal persistent storage (called STATS) DB## are data blocks that maintain persistent storage. Every FB call requires an associated DB but DBs can also stand alone. With "Multi-Instance" calls you can call an FB multiple times. Each instance has it's own unique inputs, outputs and DB (persistent storage). Think of it as a class in C++.
-
Hi All, I have been given the task (read 'saddle with') of reverse engineering and modifying a Siemens conveyor system. The thing uses a version of Ladder Logic (if you don't know it's a Programming system that was designed to be easy to read, I think we all know what that creates). I used a simple form Allen-Bradley form back at college (many moons ago!) I appear to have lost all reference I had for it. The situation is the system works, I don't want to risk breaking it. So if anyone has a reference it would be very nice! Glenn
-
Hi All, I have been given the task (read 'saddle with') of reverse engineering and modifying a Siemens conveyor system. The thing uses a version of Ladder Logic (if you don't know it's a Programming system that was designed to be easy to read, I think we all know what that creates). I used a simple form Allen-Bradley form back at college (many moons ago!) I appear to have lost all reference I had for it. The situation is the system works, I don't want to risk breaking it. So if anyone has a reference it would be very nice! Glenn
You can email me. In engineering, it is a very common programming standard, along with other standard you would be more familiar with. It can be converted to a more procedural style with fancy Allen-Bradley tooling, modified, then converted back. You usually want a systems integrator to do it, because you’re running equipment. Give me a shout. pjschieck@aol.com
Pete Schieck Legal/business refs: build-a-concert.com/legal
-
You can email me. In engineering, it is a very common programming standard, along with other standard you would be more familiar with. It can be converted to a more procedural style with fancy Allen-Bradley tooling, modified, then converted back. You usually want a systems integrator to do it, because you’re running equipment. Give me a shout. pjschieck@aol.com
Pete Schieck Legal/business refs: build-a-concert.com/legal
Cheers, the issue is I have do a bit a college many moons ago. I remember enough to be dangerous. Didn't know anyone in address my book, I know VHDL, C, C++, C#, Java, VB not ladder! :)
-
Cheers, the issue is I have do a bit a college many moons ago. I remember enough to be dangerous. Didn't know anyone in address my book, I know VHDL, C, C++, C#, Java, VB not ladder! :)
The coolest tip I can give to a C programmer would be that 110V is on one side of the ladder, and NEUTRAL is the other side. Each step (rung) of the ladder is a Boolean switch (or multiple) to turn ON a light. FYI: Rockwell inspection rungs are different than standard Boolean logic, so it can be tricky. But, with your procedural knowledge, it just takes a bit of converting bools to electrical ‘switches.’ PLCs (the controller) are simply arrays of Boolean-mapped (as in truth tables) relays in an electrical panel … really, really small relays. I always have to take a refresher video when I convert, as I program in C and ladder. Typical Rockwell ladder rung: If (on the left side of the ladder rung) the switch is closed (e.g. light switch)… then complete the circuit to the light circuit, which is represented as a COIL on the right of the rung. Execution order (PLC ‘scan’) is top-to-bottom of rungs. Rockwell uses ‘tasks’ to break ladders into logical sections. Good luck. Rockwell is the best.
- Pete
-
Hi, Thanks for that, I was having a minor panic attack! I have been billed as an expert, I am not, I have used Allen-Bradley (strangely while I was doing a contract at Siemens). Before that a course at college too long ago. I have access to experts Yayy CP! Glenn
Hi Glenn... I am cleaning up my inbox and I found this answer. It has been a while and I wondered how this topic evolved. My offer is still up, if you need anything just contact me.
M.D.V. ;) If something has a solution... Why do we have to worry about?. If it has no solution... For what reason do we have to worry about? Help me to understand what I'm saying, and I'll explain it better to you Rating helpful answers is nice, but saying thanks can be even nicer.
-
Hi Glenn... I am cleaning up my inbox and I found this answer. It has been a while and I wondered how this topic evolved. My offer is still up, if you need anything just contact me.
M.D.V. ;) If something has a solution... Why do we have to worry about?. If it has no solution... For what reason do we have to worry about? Help me to understand what I'm saying, and I'll explain it better to you Rating helpful answers is nice, but saying thanks can be even nicer.
Thanks alot, but that since has died a death. I'll give you the full story, my previous employer had a system for moving moulds on a conveyor belt, this was not used as it wasn't powerful enough to move the moulds (also the rollers were linked with silicon belts, rather than a chain drive). So the unit was preposed to be upgraded as they had bought next door and were going to expand into. At which point it was moved with haste not allowing me to follow through what was connected to what and dumped. In sorting through the mess I found some interesting details such as the PLC and three phase power unit were connected incorrectly all the interconnecting cables were blue and no idents on them. Jumped ship due to that and another unconnected issue when I was offered a better job else where.