More fuel for the America/Europe debate,,,,,
-
Giles wrote: France and Germany do want the US style melting pot and the UK does not I'm :~ about Germany. I'm not also sure the US realizes a melting-pot as we do in France, I rather see that as a superposition of cultures and groups rather than a melting. But maybe it is just another prejudice :) Giles wrote: We want France to be French, and the Germany Germ I'm sure Colin will be glad to hear you want also Scotland to be Scottish :-D Giles wrote: but don't want to see our cultures merge I don't think the EU is about culture merging, far from that. On the contrary, the EU is a way for regional "subcultures" to express themselves better than they could under an 'oppressive' centralized regime. Giles wrote: France has spoken and decided it does not want to embrace the UK's Anglo Saxon economics either Why was such a proposal in the constitution anyway? :confused:
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977)K(arl) wrote: I'm sure Colin will be glad to hear you want also Scotland to be Scottish Well thats a different story about someone wanting to break away from an existing Union. France has had sepratists in the south. Spain has it. Scotland has it, and in all these sepratists are in a minority. In Scotland the SNP has 6 of 59 seats, of which one is the smallest constuency in the country of 20,000 agaist an average of 70,000. If they have a majority in Scotland people would have to sit up and take notice, but until then its not happening. K(arl) wrote: I don't think the EU is about culture merging, far from that. On the contrary, the EU is a way for regional "subcultures" to express themselves better than they could under an 'oppressive' centralized regime. The thing is it is about setting up a central regime. K(arl) wrote: France has spoken and decided it does not want to embrace the UK's Anglo Saxon economics either Why was such a proposal in the constitution anyway? Yep. Its was reinforcing the EU free market pricipals, making way for reform of the common agraculture policy, leading to the scrapping of it, where a lot of french farmers do very well out of it. They would be opened up to major international competition.
"Je pense, donc je mange." - Rene Descartes 1689 - Just before his mother put his tea on the table. Shameless Plug - Distributed Database Transactions in .NET using COM+
-
K(arl) wrote: I'm not also sure the US realizes a melting-pot as we do in France Huh? You're way off the mark. While we've never actually rendered immigrants our history and assumptions are that each immigrant group becomes an integrated part of the whole, adopting and in many cases forcing some level of change to American customs. Recent (last 30 years or so) liberal (USA verson) influence and massive illegal immigration has caused some Balkinization but that is being changed as we speak. Mike "liberals were driven crazy by Bush." Me To: Dixie Sluts, M. Moore, the Boss, Bon Jovi, Clooney, Penn, Babs, Soros, Redford, Gore, Daschle - "bye bye" Me "I voted for W." Me "There you go again." RR "Flushed the Johns" Me
Mike Gaskey wrote: You're way off the mark I may be, I don't exclude this is a prejudice. Nonetheless, don't you consider yourself as a Polish-American?
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977) -
Maybe you should define what you mean by "melting pot". In the US, we have always understood that to mean that people come here from all over with various cultures and those all end up getting stirred into the mix, but that the soup itself remains "American". That is, we tolerate the occasional cultural differences, but expect everyone who comes here to adapt to the American culture. I can't imagine a nation doing that any better than we have always done. (Traditionally, anyway). "Capitalism is the source of all true freedom."
Stan Shannon wrote: I can't imagine a nation doing that any better than we have always done You really lack of imagination ;P
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977) -
Stan Shannon wrote: I can't imagine a nation doing that any better than we have always done You really lack of imagination ;P
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977)K(arl) wrote: You really lack of imagination Maybe so, but how could we have done better? "Capitalism is the source of all true freedom."
-
K(arl) wrote: I'm sure Colin will be glad to hear you want also Scotland to be Scottish Well thats a different story about someone wanting to break away from an existing Union. France has had sepratists in the south. Spain has it. Scotland has it, and in all these sepratists are in a minority. In Scotland the SNP has 6 of 59 seats, of which one is the smallest constuency in the country of 20,000 agaist an average of 70,000. If they have a majority in Scotland people would have to sit up and take notice, but until then its not happening. K(arl) wrote: I don't think the EU is about culture merging, far from that. On the contrary, the EU is a way for regional "subcultures" to express themselves better than they could under an 'oppressive' centralized regime. The thing is it is about setting up a central regime. K(arl) wrote: France has spoken and decided it does not want to embrace the UK's Anglo Saxon economics either Why was such a proposal in the constitution anyway? Yep. Its was reinforcing the EU free market pricipals, making way for reform of the common agraculture policy, leading to the scrapping of it, where a lot of french farmers do very well out of it. They would be opened up to major international competition.
"Je pense, donc je mange." - Rene Descartes 1689 - Just before his mother put his tea on the table. Shameless Plug - Distributed Database Transactions in .NET using COM+
Giles wrote: France has had sepratists in the south. There are separatists in Brittany (discredited after WW2, some breton separatists having collaborated with the Nazis), Savoy[^] (very minority), Basque country and Corsica (for the latter, I believe most of the French are in favour of the independence of Corsica...but nobody asks for our opinion) Giles wrote: The thing is it is about setting up a central regime. We are not yet toalking about a Federation. I hope it will come someday, but we are very far from that. Giles wrote: Its was reinforcing the EU free market pricipals And this has nothing to do in a constitution. Then the feeling there was a kind of trap. Giles wrote: where a lot of french farmers do very well out of it Agreed. Farmers are a minority, but which is very virulent and potentially violent, that's why governements (whatever their orientation) don't dare to go against their interests. Farmers are either right wingers howling against State intervention but keen to get subsidies or left wingers hippies believing in 'communitarism': a bunch of people out-of-touch, IMO.
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977) -
K(arl) wrote: You really lack of imagination Maybe so, but how could we have done better? "Capitalism is the source of all true freedom."
What about not having exterminated the Indians, for instance, and integrated them in the community? Also, is it easy to be a black man and living in the Deep South? I don't throw the first stone, we have many problems linked to integration[^] too
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977) -
Mike Gaskey wrote: You're way off the mark I may be, I don't exclude this is a prejudice. Nonetheless, don't you consider yourself as a Polish-American?
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977)K(arl) wrote: Nonetheless, don't you consider yourself as a Polish-American? No. I consider myself as an American whose heritage is Polish. I absolutely abhor designations you see in the news. The terms, for example: African-Americans, Mexican-Americans, etc - are absolutely stupid and should be outlawed. Back to the Polish thing. This influences the lens that I view things through. I am stubborn, as an example, and once I decide to do something I will not let anything stop me. That is an attribute (or non-attribute) that I credit to my Polish extraction. Mike "liberals were driven crazy by Bush." Me To: Dixie Sluts, M. Moore, the Boss, Bon Jovi, Clooney, Penn, Babs, Soros, Redford, Gore, Daschle - "bye bye" Me "I voted for W." Me "There you go again." RR "Flushed the Johns" Me
-
Giles wrote: France has had sepratists in the south. There are separatists in Brittany (discredited after WW2, some breton separatists having collaborated with the Nazis), Savoy[^] (very minority), Basque country and Corsica (for the latter, I believe most of the French are in favour of the independence of Corsica...but nobody asks for our opinion) Giles wrote: The thing is it is about setting up a central regime. We are not yet toalking about a Federation. I hope it will come someday, but we are very far from that. Giles wrote: Its was reinforcing the EU free market pricipals And this has nothing to do in a constitution. Then the feeling there was a kind of trap. Giles wrote: where a lot of french farmers do very well out of it Agreed. Farmers are a minority, but which is very virulent and potentially violent, that's why governements (whatever their orientation) don't dare to go against their interests. Farmers are either right wingers howling against State intervention but keen to get subsidies or left wingers hippies believing in 'communitarism': a bunch of people out-of-touch, IMO.
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977)K(arl) wrote: There are separatists in Brittany (discredited after WW2, some breton separatists having collaborated with the Nazis), Savoy[^] (very minority), Basque country and Corsica (for the latter, I believe most of the French are in favour of the independence of Corsica...but nobody asks for our opinion) More then than I thought. K(arl) wrote: And this has nothing to do in a constitution. Then the feeling there was a kind of trap. One of the reasons the EU was set up was that free trade helps avoid wars. The common market, and they were trying to reinforce that. K(arl) wrote: Agreed. Farmers are a minority, but which is very virulent and potentially violent, that's why governements (whatever their orientation) don't dare to go against their interests. Farmers are either right wingers howling against State intervention but keen to get subsidies or left wingers hippies believing in 'communitarism': a bunch of people out-of-touch, IMO. As far as I am aware its it only French farmers that act like this. e.g. setting fire to sheep in the capital. I know of no other european country today where farmers act like this and are so feared by their government.
"Je pense, donc je mange." - Rene Descartes 1689 - Just before his mother put his tea on the table. Shameless Plug - Distributed Database Transactions in .NET using COM+
-
K(arl) wrote: Nonetheless, don't you consider yourself as a Polish-American? No. I consider myself as an American whose heritage is Polish. I absolutely abhor designations you see in the news. The terms, for example: African-Americans, Mexican-Americans, etc - are absolutely stupid and should be outlawed. Back to the Polish thing. This influences the lens that I view things through. I am stubborn, as an example, and once I decide to do something I will not let anything stop me. That is an attribute (or non-attribute) that I credit to my Polish extraction. Mike "liberals were driven crazy by Bush." Me To: Dixie Sluts, M. Moore, the Boss, Bon Jovi, Clooney, Penn, Babs, Soros, Redford, Gore, Daschle - "bye bye" Me "I voted for W." Me "There you go again." RR "Flushed the Johns" Me
Mike Gaskey wrote: The terms, for example: African-Americans, Mexican-Americans, etc - are absolutely stupid and should be outlawed. I was fooled by these denominations, I stand corrected now. Mike Gaskey wrote: hat is an attribute (or non-attribute) that I credit to my Polish extraction. I'm not from polish origin, but I'm stubborn too! :-D
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977) -
K(arl) wrote: There are separatists in Brittany (discredited after WW2, some breton separatists having collaborated with the Nazis), Savoy[^] (very minority), Basque country and Corsica (for the latter, I believe most of the French are in favour of the independence of Corsica...but nobody asks for our opinion) More then than I thought. K(arl) wrote: And this has nothing to do in a constitution. Then the feeling there was a kind of trap. One of the reasons the EU was set up was that free trade helps avoid wars. The common market, and they were trying to reinforce that. K(arl) wrote: Agreed. Farmers are a minority, but which is very virulent and potentially violent, that's why governements (whatever their orientation) don't dare to go against their interests. Farmers are either right wingers howling against State intervention but keen to get subsidies or left wingers hippies believing in 'communitarism': a bunch of people out-of-touch, IMO. As far as I am aware its it only French farmers that act like this. e.g. setting fire to sheep in the capital. I know of no other european country today where farmers act like this and are so feared by their government.
"Je pense, donc je mange." - Rene Descartes 1689 - Just before his mother put his tea on the table. Shameless Plug - Distributed Database Transactions in .NET using COM+
Giles wrote: I know of no other european country today where farmers act like this and are so feared by their government. In western europe, there is no country where agriculture is so important. 'We' are still a rural country in many ways. Don't hesitate to cross the Channel and have a look :)
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977) -
What about not having exterminated the Indians, for instance, and integrated them in the community? Also, is it easy to be a black man and living in the Deep South? I don't throw the first stone, we have many problems linked to integration[^] too
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977)That is a bit like comparing modern France to Caesars conquest of Gaul - a bit bloody if I recall. Last mother's day, I went to buy a card for my wife. There were three families there buying mother's day cards also. All three of them were racially mixed (white-black) couples and that was in Knoxville, TN. In fact, you would be hard pressed to find a white family in the South that does not have a part African grandchild or nephew/neice. Not to ignore lingering racism, but I think we can say the problem has been largely dealt with. "Capitalism is the source of all true freedom."
-
Giles wrote: I know of no other european country today where farmers act like this and are so feared by their government. In western europe, there is no country where agriculture is so important. 'We' are still a rural country in many ways. Don't hesitate to cross the Channel and have a look :)
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977)K(arl) wrote: In western europe, there is no country where agriculture is so important. 'We' are still a rural country in many ways. Don't hesitate to cross the Channel and have a look I know it is. I've lost count of the times I've visted France on holiday. Been doing it since I was a child, and have kept it up with my wife who is also a fan. We probably pop over about once a year. Last time I was over was just before Chirtmas. Though I won't make it again until April next year when my wife and I, along with a small group of freinds plan to rent a cottage for a couple of weeks, though we have not decided on where yet. Any recommendations? There are still lots of countries in Europe with an agraculture based economy, its just in France the farmers are something to be feared as when they get upset they really get upset. Funnily enough our farmers took a leaf out of the french farmer book and held the country to ransom a couple of years ago over petrol prices. They blockaded the fuel refineries around the country causing shortages, along with go slow protests on motorways. Was quite good to watch. Funnily the problem was made much worse as everyone went out at the first sign of trouble and filled up their cars, causing normal 2 weeks worth of supply to only last 3 days, which made the problem worse, and caused it to feed on itself, in a nice example of a natural feedback loop. It was as if we could have been watching ants, except they are smarter and have natural cutoffs for that kind of thing. :laugh:
"Je pense, donc je mange." - Rene Descartes 1689 - Just before his mother put his tea on the table. Shameless Plug - Distributed Database Transactions in .NET using COM+
-
That is a bit like comparing modern France to Caesars conquest of Gaul - a bit bloody if I recall. Last mother's day, I went to buy a card for my wife. There were three families there buying mother's day cards also. All three of them were racially mixed (white-black) couples and that was in Knoxville, TN. In fact, you would be hard pressed to find a white family in the South that does not have a part African grandchild or nephew/neice. Not to ignore lingering racism, but I think we can say the problem has been largely dealt with. "Capitalism is the source of all true freedom."
Stan Shannon wrote: In fact, you would be hard pressed to find a white family in the South that does not have a part African grandchild or nephew/neice. I have a great grandson - half and half (Dallas) I have a niece - half and half (Omaha) Mike "liberals were driven crazy by Bush." Me To: Dixie Sluts, M. Moore, the Boss, Bon Jovi, Clooney, Penn, Babs, Soros, Redford, Gore, Daschle - "bye bye" Me "I voted for W." Me "There you go again." RR "Flushed the Johns" Me
-
Stan Shannon wrote: In fact, you would be hard pressed to find a white family in the South that does not have a part African grandchild or nephew/neice. I have a great grandson - half and half (Dallas) I have a niece - half and half (Omaha) Mike "liberals were driven crazy by Bush." Me To: Dixie Sluts, M. Moore, the Boss, Bon Jovi, Clooney, Penn, Babs, Soros, Redford, Gore, Daschle - "bye bye" Me "I voted for W." Me "There you go again." RR "Flushed the Johns" Me
Just out of curiosity, do they face much racism? Nature seems to be following its usually course as the rediculous, artificial, barriers of the past appear to have collapsed entirely. But I might be ignorant of the lingering challanges children of "mixed race" (even that phrase no longer seems to make any sense) are still confronted with. "Capitalism is the source of all true freedom."
-
K(arl) wrote: Nonetheless, don't you consider yourself as a Polish-American? No. I consider myself as an American whose heritage is Polish. I absolutely abhor designations you see in the news. The terms, for example: African-Americans, Mexican-Americans, etc - are absolutely stupid and should be outlawed. Back to the Polish thing. This influences the lens that I view things through. I am stubborn, as an example, and once I decide to do something I will not let anything stop me. That is an attribute (or non-attribute) that I credit to my Polish extraction. Mike "liberals were driven crazy by Bush." Me To: Dixie Sluts, M. Moore, the Boss, Bon Jovi, Clooney, Penn, Babs, Soros, Redford, Gore, Daschle - "bye bye" Me "I voted for W." Me "There you go again." RR "Flushed the Johns" Me
Mike Gaskey wrote: I credit to my Polish extraction. Are you sure it is just not a mid-western attribute? My wife isn't Polish, but from a long time hoosier family, and all of them are the most stubborn people I have ever met. "Capitalism is the source of all true freedom."
-
Just out of curiosity, do they face much racism? Nature seems to be following its usually course as the rediculous, artificial, barriers of the past appear to have collapsed entirely. But I might be ignorant of the lingering challanges children of "mixed race" (even that phrase no longer seems to make any sense) are still confronted with. "Capitalism is the source of all true freedom."
Stan Shannon wrote: Just out of curiosity, do they face much racism? Not that I have been made aware of. The niece turned out to be drop dead good looking, recently graduated from college and is sharp as a tack. The great grandson is so doted on that I think he'll be well protected from anything serious. I may be glossing over some things though. My oldest son married a Korean (met her while stationed in Korea). They have 3 children and now in his 18th year in the service he has been trained as an EOC officer, someone who deal with prejudice on a day to day basis. He believes his children are sometimes the subject of racist bias because they are different, but my belief is that ihe is just an overly protective father. Some of his reaction is based on a new found sensitivity. I think some of what he reacts to is jealousy beause these guys are all very attractive, atheletic and smart. They may be picked on a bit for those reasons. Mike "liberals were driven crazy by Bush." Me To: Dixie Sluts, M. Moore, the Boss, Bon Jovi, Clooney, Penn, Babs, Soros, Redford, Gore, Daschle - "bye bye" Me "I voted for W." Me "There you go again." RR "Flushed the Johns" Me
-
Mike Gaskey wrote: The terms, for example: African-Americans, Mexican-Americans, etc - are absolutely stupid and should be outlawed. I was fooled by these denominations, I stand corrected now. Mike Gaskey wrote: hat is an attribute (or non-attribute) that I credit to my Polish extraction. I'm not from polish origin, but I'm stubborn too! :-D
Fold with us!
Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted - Groucho Marx (1890-1977)K(arl) wrote: but I'm stubborn too! could we share some DNA? Mike "liberals were driven crazy by Bush." Me To: Dixie Sluts, M. Moore, the Boss, Bon Jovi, Clooney, Penn, Babs, Soros, Redford, Gore, Daschle - "bye bye" Me "I voted for W." Me "There you go again." RR "Flushed the Johns" Me
-
Stan Shannon wrote: Just out of curiosity, do they face much racism? Not that I have been made aware of. The niece turned out to be drop dead good looking, recently graduated from college and is sharp as a tack. The great grandson is so doted on that I think he'll be well protected from anything serious. I may be glossing over some things though. My oldest son married a Korean (met her while stationed in Korea). They have 3 children and now in his 18th year in the service he has been trained as an EOC officer, someone who deal with prejudice on a day to day basis. He believes his children are sometimes the subject of racist bias because they are different, but my belief is that ihe is just an overly protective father. Some of his reaction is based on a new found sensitivity. I think some of what he reacts to is jealousy beause these guys are all very attractive, atheletic and smart. They may be picked on a bit for those reasons. Mike "liberals were driven crazy by Bush." Me To: Dixie Sluts, M. Moore, the Boss, Bon Jovi, Clooney, Penn, Babs, Soros, Redford, Gore, Daschle - "bye bye" Me "I voted for W." Me "There you go again." RR "Flushed the Johns" Me
I think the only thing that surprises me about interracial families is how commonly excepted it appears to be. I'm sure there are people out and about who are really bothered by it, but for the most part you can go to almost any section of the country, to almost any economic category of people (poor,middle class, rich) and find interracial children living as accepted and cherished members of those communities. I think it is kind of sad that we can't celebrate this accomplishment as much as we otherwise might simply becuase it flies in the face of the "Racist American" myth promoted by the media and certain political groups. "Capitalism is the source of all true freedom."
-
I think the only thing that surprises me about interracial families is how commonly excepted it appears to be. I'm sure there are people out and about who are really bothered by it, but for the most part you can go to almost any section of the country, to almost any economic category of people (poor,middle class, rich) and find interracial children living as accepted and cherished members of those communities. I think it is kind of sad that we can't celebrate this accomplishment as much as we otherwise might simply becuase it flies in the face of the "Racist American" myth promoted by the media and certain political groups. "Capitalism is the source of all true freedom."
Stan Shannon wrote: I think the only thing that surprises me about interracial families is how commonly excepted (I think you meant accepted)it appears to be. Here's an interesting observation and it might address how this dichotomy exists. My father-in-law (just passed away at age 86) was an "old country" Pollock. He absolutely not see a black athlete without a derogotory remark such as, "jungle bunny". But at the same time it was his daughter that was married to a black man and bore the child I referred to. When he saw her (the child) he never saw her color, he only saw a grandchild. The net of this is that folks who are racists are (for the most part) only so when considering someone outside of their own family. I also think it is accurate to say that the racial problem can be cured within 2 generations, if: The majority of famlies have one instance of interracial marriage (or child birth) within "touching" distance. Blacks downplay victimhood and get on with life. Mike "liberals were driven crazy by Bush." Me To: Dixie Sluts, M. Moore, the Boss, Bon Jovi, Clooney, Penn, Babs, Soros, Redford, Gore, Daschle - "bye bye" Me "I voted for W." Me "There you go again." RR "Flushed the Johns" Me
-
Mike Gaskey wrote: I credit to my Polish extraction. Are you sure it is just not a mid-western attribute? My wife isn't Polish, but from a long time hoosier family, and all of them are the most stubborn people I have ever met. "Capitalism is the source of all true freedom."
Stan Shannon wrote: Are you sure it is just not a mid-western attribute? I don't think so. I was born and raised (until age 16) in a steel mill suburb of Pittsburgh. Relocated to Texas in '61. Lived in Mass (surrounded by liberals) for 3 years. Relocated to Indy in '89. It is genetic. I think there was a Pollock in the closet somewhere back in her lineage. Unless she's related to (K)arl. Mike "liberals were driven crazy by Bush." Me To: Dixie Sluts, M. Moore, the Boss, Bon Jovi, Clooney, Penn, Babs, Soros, Redford, Gore, Daschle - "bye bye" Me "I voted for W." Me "There you go again." RR "Flushed the Johns" Me