VGirish???
-
Dominik Reichl wrote: In my opinion these articles should be removed from CodeProject. Guys! Come on. :omg: The more articles the better for CP in general. If the articles aren't great, then maybe they should just stay as "unedited user contributions". I'd be rilly insulted if I went to the trouble of writing and posting an article and then to be told, "it's krap, rather don't bother again." Just my 2 cents worth of a troll. Cheers, Simon "Sign up for a chance to be among the first to experience the wrath of the gods.", Microsoft's home page (24/06/2002)
SimonS wrote: The more articles the better for CP in general. Well, but now compare for example Planet Source Code and CodeProject. At CodeProject you find excellent, interesting, informative articles and at Planet Source Code, you can find excellent articles too, but there are so many "not so good" articles that it isn't really funny to browse through all the articles. :mad: SimonS wrote: If the articles aren't great, then maybe they should just stay as "unedited user contributions". This would be a solution... yes... X|
-
Dominik Reichl wrote: In my opinion these articles should be removed from CodeProject. Guys! Come on. :omg: The more articles the better for CP in general. If the articles aren't great, then maybe they should just stay as "unedited user contributions". I'd be rilly insulted if I went to the trouble of writing and posting an article and then to be told, "it's krap, rather don't bother again." Just my 2 cents worth of a troll. Cheers, Simon "Sign up for a chance to be among the first to experience the wrath of the gods.", Microsoft's home page (24/06/2002)
SimonS wrote: The more articles the better for CP in general. Not exactly, IMHO. The more quality content, the better for CP... SimonS wrote: I'd be rilly insulted if I went to the trouble of writing and posting an article and then to be told, "it's krap, rather don't bother again." It could be said more diplomatic, like "you need to write some more text, explaining what you are doing in the code, and how it works" - Anders Money talks, but all mine ever says is "Goodbye!"
-
Hi! Have you noticed that "VGirish" posted 11 unedited articles at once?!?!?! Have a look at the new articles list! -Dominik
I think that if the articles hadn't been unedited that some of them wouldn't have made it. I;ve written some stuff aimed at students just starting to learn code that Chris rejected as being too simple for CP. Because VGirish chose to put them in unedited he can put in what he wants. At least that's the way I understand it. Besides somebody may find it useful and in the end that's why we write these things. It's certainly not for the glory or the trolling. Anthony
-
i just read one of them.....but there was no article, just code.
:bob: Email: theeclypse@hotmail.com URL: http://www.onyeyiri.co.uk:bob:
"What goes up must come down. Ask any system administrator"
It seems that VGirish puts all his articles between < pre > tags so they get a nice yellow background :-D
-
SimonS wrote: The more articles the better for CP in general. Not exactly, IMHO. The more quality content, the better for CP... SimonS wrote: I'd be rilly insulted if I went to the trouble of writing and posting an article and then to be told, "it's krap, rather don't bother again." It could be said more diplomatic, like "you need to write some more text, explaining what you are doing in the code, and how it works" - Anders Money talks, but all mine ever says is "Goodbye!"
-
I think that if the articles hadn't been unedited that some of them wouldn't have made it. I;ve written some stuff aimed at students just starting to learn code that Chris rejected as being too simple for CP. Because VGirish chose to put them in unedited he can put in what he wants. At least that's the way I understand it. Besides somebody may find it useful and in the end that's why we write these things. It's certainly not for the glory or the trolling. Anthony
-
I think that if the articles hadn't been unedited that some of them wouldn't have made it. I;ve written some stuff aimed at students just starting to learn code that Chris rejected as being too simple for CP. Because VGirish chose to put them in unedited he can put in what he wants. At least that's the way I understand it. Besides somebody may find it useful and in the end that's why we write these things. It's certainly not for the glory or the trolling. Anthony
It's certainly not for the glory or the trolling. It's not? Sh*t!
-
I think that if the articles hadn't been unedited that some of them wouldn't have made it. I;ve written some stuff aimed at students just starting to learn code that Chris rejected as being too simple for CP. Because VGirish chose to put them in unedited he can put in what he wants. At least that's the way I understand it. Besides somebody may find it useful and in the end that's why we write these things. It's certainly not for the glory or the trolling. Anthony
Anthony Roach wrote: I;ve written some stuff aimed at students just starting to learn code that Chris rejected as being too simple for CP. Anthony, if you don't mind sharing could you tell me what these articles were? I am amazed that anything would be rejected at all. I haven't posted anything as everything seems to have already been done and I can't find something that would be useful to others that I can actually create with any real command. Also, thanks for the symapthy expressed below. I am too tired and need to get to bed now to respond to this thread and mine. Michael Martin Australia mjm68@tpg.com.au "In Summer, I like to dance naked on the roof to celebrate the event of the temperature finally falling below 40C (usually about midnight). But the neighbors have lately taken up the habit of staying up late. And looking up, at times, from their dreary, pointless lives..." - Roger Wright 15/05/2002
-
I thought all articles went into the unedited category first? Cheers, Simon "Sign up for a chance to be among the first to experience the wrath of the gods.", Microsoft's home page (24/06/2002)
Only if you use the submission wizard... You can also write the article and send it to chris, then it starts in the edited sections... - Anders Money talks, but all mine ever says is "Goodbye!"
-
Dominik Reichl wrote: In my opinion these articles should be removed from CodeProject. Guys! Come on. :omg: The more articles the better for CP in general. If the articles aren't great, then maybe they should just stay as "unedited user contributions". I'd be rilly insulted if I went to the trouble of writing and posting an article and then to be told, "it's krap, rather don't bother again." Just my 2 cents worth of a troll. Cheers, Simon "Sign up for a chance to be among the first to experience the wrath of the gods.", Microsoft's home page (24/06/2002)
-
It seems that VGirish puts all his articles between < pre > tags so they get a nice yellow background :-D
ohh, didnt see that.
:bob: Email: theeclypse@hotmail.com URL: http://www.onyeyiri.co.uk:bob:
"What goes up must come down. Ask any system administrator"
-
Hi! Have you noticed that "VGirish" posted 11 unedited articles at once?!?!?! Have a look at the new articles list! -Dominik
Chris and I used to get this all the time at CodeGuru and of course, Chris still gets it here. I personally don't think the "articles" are that bad. They just need to be edited such that the comments are moved into regular text so that there's something besides code. The editor then needs to add a few sentences here and there to "beef up the explanations" a bit. Not that big a deal. Probably would take about 15-20 minutes an article and these articles would be find a advertised - beginner-level tips. Cheers, Tom Archer Author - Inside C#, Visual C++.NET Bible
-
SimonS wrote: The more articles the better for CP in general. Nooooooo Please don't turn CP into Planet Source Code, quality articles only.. May the Source be with you Sonork ID 100.9997 sijinjoseph
Exactly my opinion! :)
-
Only if you use the submission wizard... You can also write the article and send it to chris, then it starts in the edited sections... - Anders Money talks, but all mine ever says is "Goodbye!"
-
I prefer dealing with bots. ;P Cheers, Simon "Sign up for a chance to be among the first to experience the wrath of the gods.", Microsoft's home page (24/06/2002)
LOL :laugh: - Anders Money talks, but all mine ever says is "Goodbye!"
-
i just read one of them.....but there was no article, just code.
:bob: Email: theeclypse@hotmail.com URL: http://www.onyeyiri.co.uk:bob:
"What goes up must come down. Ask any system administrator"
Several do have explanations, but they're embedded as comments. As an editor, I'd simply move the comments to the text. I don't think the "articles" are in that bad a shape. Trust me, I've had to edit MUCH worse. Cheers, Tom Archer Author - Inside C#, Visual C++.NET Bible
-
All articles are pieces of ****. 1 point is too much. Bad article formatting, no real contents, no examples, no links work, etc... Chris, can you remove all this **** articles?
I think the articles answers some common newbie questions. Better formatting, some more article text and the addition of the 'beginner' keyword would make them really nice. Downrating them right now would just prevent the author from improving them. /moliate
Two o'clock and walking through familiar London - Or what was familiar London before the cursor deleted certain certainties - I watch a suit and tie man giving suck to the Psion Organizer lodged in his breast pocket its serial interface like a cool mouth hunting his chest for sustenance, familiar feeling, and I'm watching my breath steam in the air.
Neil Gaiman - Cold Colours
-
Hi! Have you noticed that "VGirish" posted 11 unedited articles at once?!?!?! Have a look at the new articles list! -Dominik
Hi pals, First i would like to tell you that, I am NOT that stupid enough to keep posting small articles. Secondly, i didnt know that the posts would turn up in the first page itself which is why the commotion is all about. And i wonder why the guys are going up for everything ??? I know pretty well that if there is any bad post, chris and tom are going to get it removed. I've been an Elite member of codeguru.com for a long time and its not the first discussion board where i've been. I just wanted to join codeproject as a regular member too and see the response that i get from the guys here. I'm sorry to say that my first experience was not that good as i expected. Anything done here is NOT for any practical gains, its just that the editor wants to contribute something to the other people. And i think that the INTENTION rather than the CONTENT would have to be dealt with and not just start off a debate rather than doing something constructive. Thanks folks for this debate. I wanted to start off with beginner level entries bcoz i wanted to get a FEEL of this site before i start off with something serious. But, now, thanks to this debate, i've got my own reservations. All luck and have a great time pal. p.s. The next time, do something creative rather than discussion about tom,dick or harry. If u are still upset, better write some tutorials or articles yourself ( SOME GOOD ONES WHICH U WANT ) and post them for the knowledge of the public. :-O With warm regards, V.Girish
-
Anthony Roach wrote: I;ve written some stuff aimed at students just starting to learn code that Chris rejected as being too simple for CP. Anthony, if you don't mind sharing could you tell me what these articles were? I am amazed that anything would be rejected at all. I haven't posted anything as everything seems to have already been done and I can't find something that would be useful to others that I can actually create with any real command. Also, thanks for the symapthy expressed below. I am too tired and need to get to bed now to respond to this thread and mine. Michael Martin Australia mjm68@tpg.com.au "In Summer, I like to dance naked on the roof to celebrate the event of the temperature finally falling below 40C (usually about midnight). But the neighbors have lately taken up the habit of staying up late. And looking up, at times, from their dreary, pointless lives..." - Roger Wright 15/05/2002
It's at http://www.tonysopensource.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/ The PolyMorphic CSharp essay Anthony
-
Hi pals, First i would like to tell you that, I am NOT that stupid enough to keep posting small articles. Secondly, i didnt know that the posts would turn up in the first page itself which is why the commotion is all about. And i wonder why the guys are going up for everything ??? I know pretty well that if there is any bad post, chris and tom are going to get it removed. I've been an Elite member of codeguru.com for a long time and its not the first discussion board where i've been. I just wanted to join codeproject as a regular member too and see the response that i get from the guys here. I'm sorry to say that my first experience was not that good as i expected. Anything done here is NOT for any practical gains, its just that the editor wants to contribute something to the other people. And i think that the INTENTION rather than the CONTENT would have to be dealt with and not just start off a debate rather than doing something constructive. Thanks folks for this debate. I wanted to start off with beginner level entries bcoz i wanted to get a FEEL of this site before i start off with something serious. But, now, thanks to this debate, i've got my own reservations. All luck and have a great time pal. p.s. The next time, do something creative rather than discussion about tom,dick or harry. If u are still upset, better write some tutorials or articles yourself ( SOME GOOD ONES WHICH U WANT ) and post them for the knowledge of the public. :-O With warm regards, V.Girish
Sorry you didn't feel welcomed. Perhaps it would be better to post 1 or 2 articles at first to get your feet wet. Also, there is a standard format for articles. Yours don't completely comply. Some suggestions: Don't put the entire article in "pre" tags, just code segments. Don't exceed 600 pixels width or else the text will flow off the right edge. Clearly identify articles as Beginner. Use the article template that's available on the site. Don't give up. Ed BTW: The Nazi symbolism in the photo at the bottom of your home page may not be appreciated by some.