Why would you read a book !
-
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
-
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
I rarely read technical books because I tend to need the information when I'm online, and otherwise technical books are totally boring. There are a few exceptions, but then again, I'd almost rather read them online as well. Books are great to read in bed, to take with you when you know you'll be waiting around for a while, to read on an airplane, and so forth. But I prefer books ranging from sci-fi to biographical to "self-help" (like The China Study), rather than technical books. Otherwise, I agree with your friend, except that the more stuff put online, the harder it is to weed out the garbage. I keep saying it, and I've said it for 20 years now, the next revolution isn't going to be in information, it's going to be in information searching. We still have crappy search tools. Marc
-
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
Benefits of the book - by me: 1) They're cheap, so you mind much less leaving one on a bus/plane/train than leaving a laptop(or whatever) on a bus/plane/train. 2) Books are portable, require no power and are unlikely to crash at the least opportune moment. 3) Even a cheaply printed book is far easier on the eye than a computer screen. 4) Books can be taken into the bath without fear. 5) Bookmarking is as easy a turning the corner of a page, adding a piece of paper or using a post it. 6) You're unlikely to get mugged because of your book. 7) You can annotate books however you want. 8) You can lend a book to anyone you wish without reprisal. 9) Books are not DRM protected. 10) The "book format" doesn't become obsolete. 11) They're durable and long lasting. 12) When friends come around, they'll be impressed by your collection - and will ask to borrow from it. Nah, the book is here to stay. :)
-
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
To get started with a new technology a book is great. 'Windows Presentation Foundation Unleashed' was a fantastic start into the world of WPF. Now I mostly follow blogs and the quality of the articles up here on codeproject is simply astonishing. (Thanks Josh Smith and co) But books are not just about information... Most books I read are business related (management and software engineering) and they make a huge impression on my life. Some of the books out there are just treasures packed with useful information, written by professionals. I need to read it on paper and be able to scribble on it, mark text blocks ect. to get the full benefit. Furthermore I learn because I read the whole book that covers a broad topic. I couldn't search for this in the first place because I don't know about it yet...
Listen to the toad! www.dotnettoad.com[^]
-
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
I find none of your statememts compelling. Some in the other replies are. Books are relaxing, they get me away from the computer.
-
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
Besides reading, a book has the following unusual benefits: 1. You can sit on it at a place with no chair. 2. Use it to kill undesired insects (roach, spider, etc.). 3. If it is a hardcopy, you can use it as a weapon in self-defense if you happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. 4. A good sleeping aid (works faster than sleeping pills). There are other uses which I would rather not mention here ... :-D
My .NET Business Application Framework My Home Page My Younger Son & His "PET"
-
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
IMHO, books have advantages over the web or ebooks as a medium. They also have significant disadvantages. The key (to my enjoyment) is to maximize the former and minimize the latter: Bad: Books that require me to search for definitions, explanations, references, etc... I can search through an online document much faster and more easily. Good: Books that present pictures, diagrams, or code listings with the text referencing them on the facing page - even on a wide-screen PC, the two-page layout thing doesn't work so well. Good: Books that provide a narrative account of... something. I don't care if it's an actual story or just the author leading me through the construction of a program, but when i can curl up with a paperback, holding the spine in one hand so that i can hold a beer or rest my head on the other it is relaxing in a way that holding a laptop isn't. Which means i focus more on the text. Which means i retain more of it. Bad: Books that use references like a C programmer uses macros. Nothing like curling up on a long trip with a book, only to find half-way through the first chapter that it's referring to something else constantly, and until i read that thing i'm not going to get any of it. The worst ones refer to websites for anything non-trivial - these texts have absolutely no business being printed, since they so obviously want to be blog posts. Good: use creative diagrams. Don't do code - text - code - diagram; mix it up! Annotate (and not with source comments!) the code with explanatory text, and work it into the diagram such that i learn to see the structure in the code rather than taking your word that it's there. Or use a flow diagram mixed with output mixed with a stack diagram to illuminate the runtime. Or something else. Be creative - you have better resolution and a pretty good chance that the reader can write in the margins, so don't let the 96dpi world of web publishing hold you back. Bad: Poor spelling, grammar, mistakes in code, etc. I'll let a lot of things slide onl
-
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
1. My eyes are getting old. With reading glasses, books are easier on my eyes. 2. Competent editors coupled with good checkers and good readers and peer review for one book are superior to 10 incomplete internet articles. 3. Books tend to cover subject matter in much greater depth than 99% of the internet articles you read. 4. I can take a book with me without lugging a laptop. 5. I can read on the loo without fear of dunking my laptop. 6. Books don't have hyperlinks to distract me from my original train of thought. 7. Books don't go into hibernation when I go to the frig for some milk. 8. I can put notes in the margin and place Post-It notes all over the book. 9. Unlike Internet content which sometimes disappears if a web site goes off line (like some of Fritz Onions excellent articles on asynchronous COM calls), books are around forever pretty much until the binding falls apart. 10. I get excited when a new book arrives from www.bookpool.com. I don't think books, particularly technical books have been replaced by the Internet. I do think the popular journals and magazines, (e.g. DDJ have been replaced by the Internet.)
CodeWiz51 -- Life is not a spectator sport. I came to play. Code's Musings | Code's Articles
-
Besides reading, a book has the following unusual benefits: 1. You can sit on it at a place with no chair. 2. Use it to kill undesired insects (roach, spider, etc.). 3. If it is a hardcopy, you can use it as a weapon in self-defense if you happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. 4. A good sleeping aid (works faster than sleeping pills). There are other uses which I would rather not mention here ... :-D
My .NET Business Application Framework My Home Page My Younger Son & His "PET"
ROFL! /ravi
My new year resolution: 2048 x 1536 Home | Articles | My .NET bits | Freeware ravib(at)ravib(dot)com
-
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
I like a book for a new programming language or something I have little knowledge of. That way I can highlight sections and such. If I am just looking for a small piece of information, I try the internet first. I remember when computers because more ubiquious there was the idea of "no more trees." Yet our ComSci dept. used more trees than any other department b/c professors wanted hard copies along with the code. I love to read books. I leared to read at 3 and some of my favorite memories as a child with my mom were going to the library every Saturday. My late mother was manic-depressive (sometimes called bi-polar) and it seemed in the library she was always okay and I didn't have to walk on eggshells. I love the summertime when I can sit outside and just soak up the sun and a good book.
Shhhhh..... http://craptasticnation.blogspot.com/[^]
-
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
Books provide a static reference. As long as the paper has not deteriorated you can always go back to the books reference. One of the Library of Congress' problems is concerned with the preservation of this new-fangled electronic media. They are worried, and rightly so, that future generations may find no use of data stored in electronic means if they cannot access it. Plus, it is much cheaper to throw a book at someone than a laptop.
Need a C# Consultant? I'm available.
Happiness in intelligent people is the rarest thing I know. -- Ernest Hemingway -
Books provide a static reference. As long as the paper has not deteriorated you can always go back to the books reference. One of the Library of Congress' problems is concerned with the preservation of this new-fangled electronic media. They are worried, and rightly so, that future generations may find no use of data stored in electronic means if they cannot access it. Plus, it is much cheaper to throw a book at someone than a laptop.
Need a C# Consultant? I'm available.
Happiness in intelligent people is the rarest thing I know. -- Ernest HemingwayEnnis Ray Lynch, Jr. wrote:
go back to the books reference
Good point; you never know where the information on the net came from, or how often it has changed.
Ennis Ray Lynch, Jr. wrote:
throw a book at someone than a laptop
Rocks work very well for me.
Shhhhh..... http://craptasticnation.blogspot.com/[^]
-
Benefits of the book - by me: 1) They're cheap, so you mind much less leaving one on a bus/plane/train than leaving a laptop(or whatever) on a bus/plane/train. 2) Books are portable, require no power and are unlikely to crash at the least opportune moment. 3) Even a cheaply printed book is far easier on the eye than a computer screen. 4) Books can be taken into the bath without fear. 5) Bookmarking is as easy a turning the corner of a page, adding a piece of paper or using a post it. 6) You're unlikely to get mugged because of your book. 7) You can annotate books however you want. 8) You can lend a book to anyone you wish without reprisal. 9) Books are not DRM protected. 10) The "book format" doesn't become obsolete. 11) They're durable and long lasting. 12) When friends come around, they'll be impressed by your collection - and will ask to borrow from it. Nah, the book is here to stay. :)
Cheap, portable, easier to eye, durable and personalized experience Wow thats lot of good points, ow i can argue strongly about the topic
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Author of the Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
-
I find none of your statememts compelling. Some in the other replies are. Books are relaxing, they get me away from the computer.
PIEBALDconsult wrote:
none of your statememts compelling.
:) may be thats why the argument ! books to get waya from the computer thats a good one
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Author of the Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
-
Besides reading, a book has the following unusual benefits: 1. You can sit on it at a place with no chair. 2. Use it to kill undesired insects (roach, spider, etc.). 3. If it is a hardcopy, you can use it as a weapon in self-defense if you happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. 4. A good sleeping aid (works faster than sleeping pills). There are other uses which I would rather not mention here ... :-D
My .NET Business Application Framework My Home Page My Younger Son & His "PET"
Xiangyang Liu wrote:
A good sleeping aid
Agree totally, A bad book can be a great sleeping aid , i had that experience with design patterns book by gamma et al :)
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
-
1. My eyes are getting old. With reading glasses, books are easier on my eyes. 2. Competent editors coupled with good checkers and good readers and peer review for one book are superior to 10 incomplete internet articles. 3. Books tend to cover subject matter in much greater depth than 99% of the internet articles you read. 4. I can take a book with me without lugging a laptop. 5. I can read on the loo without fear of dunking my laptop. 6. Books don't have hyperlinks to distract me from my original train of thought. 7. Books don't go into hibernation when I go to the frig for some milk. 8. I can put notes in the margin and place Post-It notes all over the book. 9. Unlike Internet content which sometimes disappears if a web site goes off line (like some of Fritz Onions excellent articles on asynchronous COM calls), books are around forever pretty much until the binding falls apart. 10. I get excited when a new book arrives from www.bookpool.com. I don't think books, particularly technical books have been replaced by the Internet. I do think the popular journals and magazines, (e.g. DDJ have been replaced by the Internet.)
CodeWiz51 -- Life is not a spectator sport. I came to play. Code's Musings | Code's Articles
CodeWizard1951 wrote:
8. I can put notes in the margin and place Post-It notes all over the book.
I think this is teh best part when you can personalize a book with your own notes, underlines etc.
CodeWizard1951 wrote:
2. Competent editors coupled with good checkers and good readers and peer review for one book are superior to 10 incomplete internet articles.
CodeWizard1951 wrote:
3. Books tend to cover subject matter in much greater depth than 99% of the internet articles you read.
for a good book, cannot agree less
CodeWizard1951 wrote:
6. Books don't have hyperlinks to distract me from my original train of thought.
:)
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
-
IMHO, books have advantages over the web or ebooks as a medium. They also have significant disadvantages. The key (to my enjoyment) is to maximize the former and minimize the latter: Bad: Books that require me to search for definitions, explanations, references, etc... I can search through an online document much faster and more easily. Good: Books that present pictures, diagrams, or code listings with the text referencing them on the facing page - even on a wide-screen PC, the two-page layout thing doesn't work so well. Good: Books that provide a narrative account of... something. I don't care if it's an actual story or just the author leading me through the construction of a program, but when i can curl up with a paperback, holding the spine in one hand so that i can hold a beer or rest my head on the other it is relaxing in a way that holding a laptop isn't. Which means i focus more on the text. Which means i retain more of it. Bad: Books that use references like a C programmer uses macros. Nothing like curling up on a long trip with a book, only to find half-way through the first chapter that it's referring to something else constantly, and until i read that thing i'm not going to get any of it. The worst ones refer to websites for anything non-trivial - these texts have absolutely no business being printed, since they so obviously want to be blog posts. Good: use creative diagrams. Don't do code - text - code - diagram; mix it up! Annotate (and not with source comments!) the code with explanatory text, and work it into the diagram such that i learn to see the structure in the code rather than taking your word that it's there. Or use a flow diagram mixed with output mixed with a stack diagram to illuminate the runtime. Or something else. Be creative - you have better resolution and a pretty good chance that the reader can write in the margins, so don't let the 96dpi world of web publishing hold you back. Bad: Poor spelling, grammar, mistakes in code, etc. I'll let a lot of things slide onl
Yes I agree, books sometimes have a unique flavour to it, which reflects th author, reminds me of the author Jeff Prosise , who has a unique style of writing. A book gives such personalized and rich experience that cannot come from online information. And yes their are advantages to online information also but I won't say that printing is dead any time in future. I find myself buying books more than ever.
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
-
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
"Smell is the most powerful trigger to the memory there is. A certain flower or a whiff of smoke can bring up experiences long forgotten. Books smell... musty and rich. The knowledge gained from a computer is... it has no texture, no context. It's there and then it's gone. If it's to last, then the getting of knowledge should be tangible. It should be, um... smelly."
------------------ John Andrew Holmes "It is well to remember that the entire universe, with one trifling exception, is composed of others."
-
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
Quartz. wrote:
printing will be dead in 10 years
He should be suffering from sort of phobia. :) Not everyone at this time can afford to be online in front of the system and even while driving, you can afford to keep reading some book but not carry a laptop always. When you fly, you are advised to switch off your electronic gadgets (including laptops) but no one refuses (or can refuse) your right to read a book. :rolleyes:
Vasudevan Deepak Kumar Personal Homepage
Tech Gossips
A pessimist sees only the dark side of the clouds, and mopes; a philosopher sees both sides, and shrugs; an optimist doesn't see the clouds at all - he's walking on them. --Leonard Louis Levinson -
A friend of mine was arguing that nowadays you can find all the information online, why would somebody buy a book ? He also claims that, printing will be dead in 10 years Well I think a book is better because, 1. It gathers all the related information together 2. The layout is in a way which is easier to understand 3. Information on the web can be inaccurate 4. Searching for information on the net can take time, a good book give you all the required information at a single place 5. A book also teaches way of doing things in a unique author's style, who can be experienced on the subject Which one would you prefer, a book, rather than searching information online or vice versa and why?
Omit Needless Words - Strunk, William, Jr.
Vista Gadget Book: Creating Vista Gadgets using HTML, CSS, & JavaScript. Sample chapter here Selling Your Gadget
A book, every time. I have a huge pile of books, I order from amazon every month, read each one and add to the pile.
Christian Graus Please read this if you don't understand the answer I've given you "also I don't think "TranslateOneToTwoBillion OneHundredAndFortySevenMillion FourHundredAndEightyThreeThousand SixHundredAndFortySeven()" is a very good choice for a function name" - SpacixOne ( offering help to someone who really needed it ) ( spaces added for the benefit of people running at < 1280x1024 )
