Am I Wrong To Doubt Tablet Computing?
-
Given Apple's astounding sales and the recent committment made by Microsoft I know the question is a bit bizarre. Many people consider the question already completely answered, and I can respect that point of view. However, I'm still in teh doubters camp - not so much about the current success but about the long term viability of tablets. To me the whole thing is still just a fad. Let me explain myself. 1: The typical PC form factor has been with us for at least 30 years and I think the reason it's enjoyed such a long streak is because it works. Laptops and notebooks have been with us for nearly as long - again, because they work. So when I call the tablet a fad I mean in comparison to more traditional form factors. 2: Traditional form factors allow for an incredible amount of customization. Different screen sizes, keyboards, mice, speakers - tons of peripherals, etc. People like cutomization beyond the color of the case - ergonomic customization is important. 3: The Microsoft Surface can ship with a keyboard. To me this suggests the tablet has a deficiency. I don't understand why someone would get a tablet with keyboard when they could get a ridiculously thin Mac Air with the keyboard (and more functionality). 4: It's true that a tablet can be used in the medical field for very specialized purposes but that has been true of medical devices since the flashlight was re-imagined as a device to peer up someone's nose. In short, just as the little nose looker thingies didn't replace flashlights I don't see the tablet replacing netbooks. This post isn't about hating on tablets, Apple, or the Surface. I think they're really slick devices but anytime I consider buying one I cannot get past the question of Why? I think in 5 years we'll all look back on the so-called post-PC era and LOL.
To begin with, certainly development is going to remain on the desktop. I see our salespeople relying on tablets because of the fast boot time, portability, etc. For them it makes no sense dragging around a laptop or ultrabook. But, let me also say at the beginning of GUIs, I was not convinced. I saw them as being slower that a command line, "DEL *.*" now became "highlight and drag to the trash". It was just slower to get any work done. And then there were the icons with each vendor having their own idea what symbol to use for each function. I feared the return of hieroglyphics until tooltips and my grandchildren were able to use the computers before they could read. My observation was that they could play games from 2 1/2, use a browser at 3 (with keyboard aids) and then from 3 1/2 on they had clicking down. Whenever an older person tells me they could never learn to use a computer, I ask them why they don't think they have the skills of a 3 year old and besides they have the advantage because they can read. My point? Tablets and their swipe recognition is even easier. Just like GUIs created a new paradigm for file manipulation, tablets may evolve a graphical symbology for linking functional blocks and the creation of graphical programming. These things have been tried before with minimal success, but with the vast ecosystem of tablets, phablets, and smartphones, there will be a market ready to exploit if you can creatively crack the design issues. Once the initial shock wears off, people are going to figure out how to exploit these devices. There is just too much money to be made. I don't expect the Gold Rush mentality of the Dotcom Boom/Bust, but using these devices will get us thinking in new ways.
Psychosis at 10 Film at 11 Those who do not remember the past, are doomed to repeat it. Those who do not remember the past, cannot build upon it.
-
Given Apple's astounding sales and the recent committment made by Microsoft I know the question is a bit bizarre. Many people consider the question already completely answered, and I can respect that point of view. However, I'm still in teh doubters camp - not so much about the current success but about the long term viability of tablets. To me the whole thing is still just a fad. Let me explain myself. 1: The typical PC form factor has been with us for at least 30 years and I think the reason it's enjoyed such a long streak is because it works. Laptops and notebooks have been with us for nearly as long - again, because they work. So when I call the tablet a fad I mean in comparison to more traditional form factors. 2: Traditional form factors allow for an incredible amount of customization. Different screen sizes, keyboards, mice, speakers - tons of peripherals, etc. People like cutomization beyond the color of the case - ergonomic customization is important. 3: The Microsoft Surface can ship with a keyboard. To me this suggests the tablet has a deficiency. I don't understand why someone would get a tablet with keyboard when they could get a ridiculously thin Mac Air with the keyboard (and more functionality). 4: It's true that a tablet can be used in the medical field for very specialized purposes but that has been true of medical devices since the flashlight was re-imagined as a device to peer up someone's nose. In short, just as the little nose looker thingies didn't replace flashlights I don't see the tablet replacing netbooks. This post isn't about hating on tablets, Apple, or the Surface. I think they're really slick devices but anytime I consider buying one I cannot get past the question of Why? I think in 5 years we'll all look back on the so-called post-PC era and LOL.
I agree. Most people jump on every single overhyped thing, because they need to seem cool and modern. The reality, at least for business, is that tablets are useless. I've never seen one person using it, for business. Why? Because it's unpractical, limited, and still cumbersome! Everything the tab can do, a laptop can do better, with more freedom. Typing an email? Have to put the tablet flat on table and start smearing your finger grease all over the thing.. Drag drop a file attachment from the deskt... Ooops, no, BUY an app for it. Wanna..? -BUY the app for it. BUY, BUY, BUY, from the single only store that allows apps for it. Anyway, I'm not on the doubter side here; I'm sure this is a flop. People use them for bs tasks, games that remind me of the early 90s. Oh, and updating their pathetic fb page as if the world is watching them, eagerly awaiting their next update. These days, new gadget, pay all the usual bloggers, websites, to make a "review". Don't be foooled by the "reviews"; 95% of them are really paid ads. And then people think "everybody says.."; but no, ask any computer geek like me, and we'll tell you what these finger-grease flat screens are good for... *points at children playing games on fb*
-
I agree. Most people jump on every single overhyped thing, because they need to seem cool and modern. The reality, at least for business, is that tablets are useless. I've never seen one person using it, for business. Why? Because it's unpractical, limited, and still cumbersome! Everything the tab can do, a laptop can do better, with more freedom. Typing an email? Have to put the tablet flat on table and start smearing your finger grease all over the thing.. Drag drop a file attachment from the deskt... Ooops, no, BUY an app for it. Wanna..? -BUY the app for it. BUY, BUY, BUY, from the single only store that allows apps for it. Anyway, I'm not on the doubter side here; I'm sure this is a flop. People use them for bs tasks, games that remind me of the early 90s. Oh, and updating their pathetic fb page as if the world is watching them, eagerly awaiting their next update. These days, new gadget, pay all the usual bloggers, websites, to make a "review". Don't be foooled by the "reviews"; 95% of them are really paid ads. And then people think "everybody says.."; but no, ask any computer geek like me, and we'll tell you what these finger-grease flat screens are good for... *points at children playing games on fb*
I remember the first time I saw a researcher back in the late '60s using a light pen interacting with a screen to draw. I think we are going to go back to that. I find using a track pad or mouse the ultimate in clumsiness compared to my fingers or a light pen. What we will end up with is using our fingers on a touchscreen or for precision work the equivalent of a light pen. Whether you call them tablets, laptops or netbooks is immaterial, we will have touchscreens with detachable keyboards.
-
:thumbsup: Well said. :thumbsup: Tablets will not likely replace laptops or desktops any time soon (if ever), but for many people they are a better fit as a replacement or a companion product.
Government is not reason; it is not eloquent; it is force. Like fire, it is a dangerous servant and a fearful master. ~ George Washington
I completely disagree. Tablets, in the sense that we know them a week ago (iPads) will not replace the common laptop; however, tablets as we're redefining them today will. I use a netbook currently (4G Ram, Dual Core, decent hard drive) as my main development and mobile computing device. I found that laptops, regardless of form factor, are too large and bulky to truly be mobile (unless you like the idea of giant "man purses" and permanent backpack apparel). When I get in front of a screen, I plug in. When I get in front of a keyboard, I plug in. I use it both as a desktop and a netbook. It gives me "enough" computing power to develop software, and is portable enough that I don't mind taking it with me. All that said, I would trade it in a heartbeat for a W8Pro tablet. If this were to happen, my habits of plugging in whenever I have the opportunity would not change, but what would change is that my convenience factor when on the go would increase 10 fold. I could have access to all my important files, my development environment, my designer environment, and my entertainment wherever I was, whenever I wanted. Compare that to a modern notebook computer. Yes, the screen is smaller, so if you have bad eyesight, I suppose that could be an issue, BUT, modern notebooks are generally underpowered graphics-wise, and tablets will be no different. Modern notebooks get hot, while tablets are not known for this. Notebooks can't be quickly turned on and touched to accomplish something quickly when on the go, and you certainly won't be using them while moving. Tablets you can. The notebook for most of us professionals (that have decent eyesight) is on its way out. I wouldn't have said that had W8 Pro not been envisioned, but being that it's here, we can see a glimpse into what the future of computing is going to look like on the go. That doesn't mean I'm giving up my desktop, mind you. The ultimate question when considering that has to be asked: "Yeah, but does it play Crysis?" No, it doesn't, and as long as a modern video card is 3-5x the depth of a tablet, it won't.
-
Given Apple's astounding sales and the recent committment made by Microsoft I know the question is a bit bizarre. Many people consider the question already completely answered, and I can respect that point of view. However, I'm still in teh doubters camp - not so much about the current success but about the long term viability of tablets. To me the whole thing is still just a fad. Let me explain myself. 1: The typical PC form factor has been with us for at least 30 years and I think the reason it's enjoyed such a long streak is because it works. Laptops and notebooks have been with us for nearly as long - again, because they work. So when I call the tablet a fad I mean in comparison to more traditional form factors. 2: Traditional form factors allow for an incredible amount of customization. Different screen sizes, keyboards, mice, speakers - tons of peripherals, etc. People like cutomization beyond the color of the case - ergonomic customization is important. 3: The Microsoft Surface can ship with a keyboard. To me this suggests the tablet has a deficiency. I don't understand why someone would get a tablet with keyboard when they could get a ridiculously thin Mac Air with the keyboard (and more functionality). 4: It's true that a tablet can be used in the medical field for very specialized purposes but that has been true of medical devices since the flashlight was re-imagined as a device to peer up someone's nose. In short, just as the little nose looker thingies didn't replace flashlights I don't see the tablet replacing netbooks. This post isn't about hating on tablets, Apple, or the Surface. I think they're really slick devices but anytime I consider buying one I cannot get past the question of Why? I think in 5 years we'll all look back on the so-called post-PC era and LOL.
When I took my current job with the school district I work for, I knew I needed something more portable than the laptop they gave me. As a campus technician, I'm responsible for maintaining all of the technology on at least five different campuses and troubleshooting any issues they run into. Occasionally I also work on other projects like site surveys for upcoming technology installs. My tablet has seriously exploded the level of productivity I'm capable of in all of these areas. I got an ASUS Transformer TF300T with a Tegra 3 quad core processor, 1GB of RAM and 32GB of internal storage. It's currently running Android 4.1.1. I did not get the optional detachable keyboard but, as I found out, I really don't need it. The on-screen keyboard is a lot more usable than I thought it would be. So what have I used it for? The digital classroom project involves installed an audio system in the drop ceiling, an interactive HD projector on the wall above the dry-erase board, electrical conduit and receptacles, and a number of connections below the board for various other pieces of technology. The site survey for this required pictures of the room, the board, and the space above the ceiling from several angles, measurements, and detailed notes for every classroom it went into. At the end of each survey, the pictures and the notes needed to be put into a report with a specific format, meaning a word document with a table that had a column for room numbers, one for pictures, and one for notes broken into a bullet point list. Instead of lugging around a laptop, a camera, and a tape measure, all I used were the tablet and the tape measure. I created the report on the tablet, took the pictures with the tablet and had them automatically placed in the right place in the report, and typed up my notes and measurements right there. No arm strain, no worry of running out of battery, no extraneous baggage or bulk. I would then upload the entire report from my tablet into our web-based file system where everyone could access it. When I'm working my tickets, I log into the ticketing system from my tablet, access stored documents on a shared drive on my laptop which I set up in a central location and leave there as I go about my business, keep track of appointments using a widget on my home screen that syncs with my outlook calendar, reset passwords and manage Active Directory user and computer accounts with ActiveDir Manager, generate network maps for subnets I'm troubleshooting devices on and ping or tracero
-
I completely disagree. Tablets, in the sense that we know them a week ago (iPads) will not replace the common laptop; however, tablets as we're redefining them today will. I use a netbook currently (4G Ram, Dual Core, decent hard drive) as my main development and mobile computing device. I found that laptops, regardless of form factor, are too large and bulky to truly be mobile (unless you like the idea of giant "man purses" and permanent backpack apparel). When I get in front of a screen, I plug in. When I get in front of a keyboard, I plug in. I use it both as a desktop and a netbook. It gives me "enough" computing power to develop software, and is portable enough that I don't mind taking it with me. All that said, I would trade it in a heartbeat for a W8Pro tablet. If this were to happen, my habits of plugging in whenever I have the opportunity would not change, but what would change is that my convenience factor when on the go would increase 10 fold. I could have access to all my important files, my development environment, my designer environment, and my entertainment wherever I was, whenever I wanted. Compare that to a modern notebook computer. Yes, the screen is smaller, so if you have bad eyesight, I suppose that could be an issue, BUT, modern notebooks are generally underpowered graphics-wise, and tablets will be no different. Modern notebooks get hot, while tablets are not known for this. Notebooks can't be quickly turned on and touched to accomplish something quickly when on the go, and you certainly won't be using them while moving. Tablets you can. The notebook for most of us professionals (that have decent eyesight) is on its way out. I wouldn't have said that had W8 Pro not been envisioned, but being that it's here, we can see a glimpse into what the future of computing is going to look like on the go. That doesn't mean I'm giving up my desktop, mind you. The ultimate question when considering that has to be asked: "Yeah, but does it play Crysis?" No, it doesn't, and as long as a modern video card is 3-5x the depth of a tablet, it won't.
-
thoiness wrote:
I completely disagree.
Typo? Because your explanation is in full agreement to what I wrote.
Government is not reason; it is not eloquent; it is force. Like fire, it is a dangerous servant and a fearful master. ~ George Washington
Perhaps more of a misunderstanding of what you wrote. On the one hand, you stated that it will never replace laptops, and on the other hand you stated for some it could serve as a replacement. My ADD must have kicked in on the second half. Perhaps mine was an elaboration of what you were trying to convey, and I just didn't catch it. :~
-
based on our business here, tablets(ipads, whatever) are handy for salespeople, bosses and managers to view reports on the fly, stay mobile with emails and whatnot. For hardcore work, its desktop all the way here. I think they have their place, and as apps get developed for them, maybe more places open up. However, I think development work will always(for the near future at least) be done on more conventional pc's of some sort. Just my opinion.
I'm beginning to hate the news...the world was much nicer when I was illiterate Be careful which toes you step on today, they might be connected to the foot that kicks your butt tomorrow. You can't scare me, I have children.
If you think the tablet is going anywhere OR that the PC / Laptop is dead you're delusional. I think it's easy to forget, as professional content creators, that there are different groups with different needs. Every non-content creator I know that has a tablet loves it. My wife has spent more time with her iPad in the last 3 years than with me during our 20 year marriage. Why? She can read her book before going to sleep, watch a movie on the train or read her email in the loo. It fits in her purse and lasts all day. And it just works. She doesn't need me to run it and she likes that (too much I think) On the flip side, the form factor prevents 'serious' work from being done. My desktop at work is 4960 x 1600 spread across 3 monitors. Not very portable but very efficient for work. I heard a great analogy once comparing computing devices to vehicles. PCs / Laptops are like Trucks. Tablets like cars. Really, most people don't need a truck, hence all the cars but not many trucks. But the people who need a truck, really do need a truck. That is why there are still trucks. Looks like we're all truck drivers. =p And this is why neither are going away - they both serve a purpose. I think it is important to remember that just because it makes no sense to you, doesn't mean it doesn't make any sense to someone else.
-
Given Apple's astounding sales and the recent committment made by Microsoft I know the question is a bit bizarre. Many people consider the question already completely answered, and I can respect that point of view. However, I'm still in teh doubters camp - not so much about the current success but about the long term viability of tablets. To me the whole thing is still just a fad. Let me explain myself. 1: The typical PC form factor has been with us for at least 30 years and I think the reason it's enjoyed such a long streak is because it works. Laptops and notebooks have been with us for nearly as long - again, because they work. So when I call the tablet a fad I mean in comparison to more traditional form factors. 2: Traditional form factors allow for an incredible amount of customization. Different screen sizes, keyboards, mice, speakers - tons of peripherals, etc. People like cutomization beyond the color of the case - ergonomic customization is important. 3: The Microsoft Surface can ship with a keyboard. To me this suggests the tablet has a deficiency. I don't understand why someone would get a tablet with keyboard when they could get a ridiculously thin Mac Air with the keyboard (and more functionality). 4: It's true that a tablet can be used in the medical field for very specialized purposes but that has been true of medical devices since the flashlight was re-imagined as a device to peer up someone's nose. In short, just as the little nose looker thingies didn't replace flashlights I don't see the tablet replacing netbooks. This post isn't about hating on tablets, Apple, or the Surface. I think they're really slick devices but anytime I consider buying one I cannot get past the question of Why? I think in 5 years we'll all look back on the so-called post-PC era and LOL.
Its all about content consumption and content creation. Tablets are optimized for content consumption. For small amounts of content creation (e.g. email, tweaking documents, adjusting pictures, basic video editing, etc.), a tablet can present a user interface that is acceptable, if not optimal. There are even some content creation actions where a tablet is an optimal input device (e.g. creating digital artwork). For significant content creation, traditional input devices are still preferable to most people. For example, I can't see writing lengthy documents with an on-screen keyboard as a viable option (well, not if I value my time, which I do). However, the two will blur together, with tablets becoming useable for both, althrough perhaps in different modes and with different input modes. The Surface is an example of such a product, my Razr phone with HDMI out and USB device master capability is a better example. Yes, we'll all lool back and LOL, but not because tablets were a dumb idea, but because we had to own several devices to optimize our phone, content consumption and content creation experiences. Check out Ubuntu for Android, that's along the direction of where we're headed.
We can program with only 1's, but if all you've got are zeros, you've got nothing.
-
You may be right, AspDotNetDev. I cannot know the future; however, I'd guess what we'll get is a 'netbook' (with full featured OS) that has a touch screen and built in keyboard. I say that because having more than we need is actually the status quo. :-D Continue with the trend of price lowering/competition and it's a logical place to take this thing. Future: Oh look, my tablet has an attached keyboard. Of course, at what point does a tablet become a netbook? Is a tablet a netbook with a detachable keyboard?
In that case you've got a "Surface" -- it's a netbook all right, especially the full-on Windows one... and the keyboard is separate: it attaches magnetically. I think that pretty much covers this idea... let's see if anyone buys them. Apparently, the top-level one has 128 Mb of Flash in it... one wonders if this will be enough.
-
A previous company I was with gave me a tablet for R&D... I hated it and couldn't use it at all. I knew another guy for a scientific research firm who received one. He hated it as well. So, my conclusion is that for people doing real computing work... tablets are useless. For people looking for entertainment, they are great. That is the only distinction I can see... one is a tool, one is a toy. And the intertainment industry is not going anywhere. I bet tablets are here to stay, but so are the PCs.
Becarefull with the "Toy" remark. I remember when they used to call Mac's "Toy Computers"
-
Given Apple's astounding sales and the recent committment made by Microsoft I know the question is a bit bizarre. Many people consider the question already completely answered, and I can respect that point of view. However, I'm still in teh doubters camp - not so much about the current success but about the long term viability of tablets. To me the whole thing is still just a fad. Let me explain myself. 1: The typical PC form factor has been with us for at least 30 years and I think the reason it's enjoyed such a long streak is because it works. Laptops and notebooks have been with us for nearly as long - again, because they work. So when I call the tablet a fad I mean in comparison to more traditional form factors. 2: Traditional form factors allow for an incredible amount of customization. Different screen sizes, keyboards, mice, speakers - tons of peripherals, etc. People like cutomization beyond the color of the case - ergonomic customization is important. 3: The Microsoft Surface can ship with a keyboard. To me this suggests the tablet has a deficiency. I don't understand why someone would get a tablet with keyboard when they could get a ridiculously thin Mac Air with the keyboard (and more functionality). 4: It's true that a tablet can be used in the medical field for very specialized purposes but that has been true of medical devices since the flashlight was re-imagined as a device to peer up someone's nose. In short, just as the little nose looker thingies didn't replace flashlights I don't see the tablet replacing netbooks. This post isn't about hating on tablets, Apple, or the Surface. I think they're really slick devices but anytime I consider buying one I cannot get past the question of Why? I think in 5 years we'll all look back on the so-called post-PC era and LOL.
-
If you think the tablet is going anywhere OR that the PC / Laptop is dead you're delusional. I think it's easy to forget, as professional content creators, that there are different groups with different needs. Every non-content creator I know that has a tablet loves it. My wife has spent more time with her iPad in the last 3 years than with me during our 20 year marriage. Why? She can read her book before going to sleep, watch a movie on the train or read her email in the loo. It fits in her purse and lasts all day. And it just works. She doesn't need me to run it and she likes that (too much I think) On the flip side, the form factor prevents 'serious' work from being done. My desktop at work is 4960 x 1600 spread across 3 monitors. Not very portable but very efficient for work. I heard a great analogy once comparing computing devices to vehicles. PCs / Laptops are like Trucks. Tablets like cars. Really, most people don't need a truck, hence all the cars but not many trucks. But the people who need a truck, really do need a truck. That is why there are still trucks. Looks like we're all truck drivers. =p And this is why neither are going away - they both serve a purpose. I think it is important to remember that just because it makes no sense to you, doesn't mean it doesn't make any sense to someone else.
MASS Productions wrote:
If you think the tablet is going anywhere OR that the PC / Laptop is dead you're delusional.
Where did I insinuate either one? I basically said that they all have their place depending on what your use is.
I'm beginning to hate the news...the world was much nicer when I was illiterate Be careful which toes you step on today, they might be connected to the foot that kicks your butt tomorrow. You can't scare me, I have children.
-
MASS Productions wrote:
If you think the tablet is going anywhere OR that the PC / Laptop is dead you're delusional.
Where did I insinuate either one? I basically said that they all have their place depending on what your use is.
I'm beginning to hate the news...the world was much nicer when I was illiterate Be careful which toes you step on today, they might be connected to the foot that kicks your butt tomorrow. You can't scare me, I have children.
lol, well, obviously that statement doesn't apply to you, it's conditional. Specifically, I was addressing anyone in the audience. It seems like there were a lot of replies and I imagine even more readers.
-
lol, well, obviously that statement doesn't apply to you, it's conditional. Specifically, I was addressing anyone in the audience. It seems like there were a lot of replies and I imagine even more readers.
ah you must have meant to post under another post maybe? I only replied since you had replied directly to mine.
I'm beginning to hate the news...the world was much nicer when I was illiterate Be careful which toes you step on today, they might be connected to the foot that kicks your butt tomorrow. You can't scare me, I have children.
-
ah you must have meant to post under another post maybe? I only replied since you had replied directly to mine.
I'm beginning to hate the news...the world was much nicer when I was illiterate Be careful which toes you step on today, they might be connected to the foot that kicks your butt tomorrow. You can't scare me, I have children.
Yes, it was just a general 2 cents being added to the conversation. My poor operation of the new interface apparently culminated in it being attached to your response.
-
Given Apple's astounding sales and the recent committment made by Microsoft I know the question is a bit bizarre. Many people consider the question already completely answered, and I can respect that point of view. However, I'm still in teh doubters camp - not so much about the current success but about the long term viability of tablets. To me the whole thing is still just a fad. Let me explain myself. 1: The typical PC form factor has been with us for at least 30 years and I think the reason it's enjoyed such a long streak is because it works. Laptops and notebooks have been with us for nearly as long - again, because they work. So when I call the tablet a fad I mean in comparison to more traditional form factors. 2: Traditional form factors allow for an incredible amount of customization. Different screen sizes, keyboards, mice, speakers - tons of peripherals, etc. People like cutomization beyond the color of the case - ergonomic customization is important. 3: The Microsoft Surface can ship with a keyboard. To me this suggests the tablet has a deficiency. I don't understand why someone would get a tablet with keyboard when they could get a ridiculously thin Mac Air with the keyboard (and more functionality). 4: It's true that a tablet can be used in the medical field for very specialized purposes but that has been true of medical devices since the flashlight was re-imagined as a device to peer up someone's nose. In short, just as the little nose looker thingies didn't replace flashlights I don't see the tablet replacing netbooks. This post isn't about hating on tablets, Apple, or the Surface. I think they're really slick devices but anytime I consider buying one I cannot get past the question of Why? I think in 5 years we'll all look back on the so-called post-PC era and LOL.
A computer expert is the very *last* person who could correctly call the tablet wave as fad or fact. Consider... If you have years of experience using the existing form factor all day, it will *of course* feel more natural to you than a new form factor. If you use computers for typing-heavy expert workloads like programming and documenting, then *of course* the keyboardless tablet will feel inadequate. If everyone around you uses existing computers for typing-heavy workloads, you may come to think that these workloads dominate computer uses. Go home and see what your mom is doing (maybe playing Solitaire) on her computer, and what your kid is doing (maybe playing angry birds on his smartphone), and you might come to a different conclusion. Honestly, I don't think anyone is left who thinks ebooks and smartphones are going away any time soon, even if you can't type on 'em. Laptops aren't going away either, unless we discover that the market segment of expert users is such a small percentage that it's no longer worth serving. In which case god help us all on this site.
-
Given Apple's astounding sales and the recent committment made by Microsoft I know the question is a bit bizarre. Many people consider the question already completely answered, and I can respect that point of view. However, I'm still in teh doubters camp - not so much about the current success but about the long term viability of tablets. To me the whole thing is still just a fad. Let me explain myself. 1: The typical PC form factor has been with us for at least 30 years and I think the reason it's enjoyed such a long streak is because it works. Laptops and notebooks have been with us for nearly as long - again, because they work. So when I call the tablet a fad I mean in comparison to more traditional form factors. 2: Traditional form factors allow for an incredible amount of customization. Different screen sizes, keyboards, mice, speakers - tons of peripherals, etc. People like cutomization beyond the color of the case - ergonomic customization is important. 3: The Microsoft Surface can ship with a keyboard. To me this suggests the tablet has a deficiency. I don't understand why someone would get a tablet with keyboard when they could get a ridiculously thin Mac Air with the keyboard (and more functionality). 4: It's true that a tablet can be used in the medical field for very specialized purposes but that has been true of medical devices since the flashlight was re-imagined as a device to peer up someone's nose. In short, just as the little nose looker thingies didn't replace flashlights I don't see the tablet replacing netbooks. This post isn't about hating on tablets, Apple, or the Surface. I think they're really slick devices but anytime I consider buying one I cannot get past the question of Why? I think in 5 years we'll all look back on the so-called post-PC era and LOL.
To me, tablets are just something to let you compute more in more places. They don't replace PCs by any stretch, but are an add-on. The primary advantages, as I see them, are: 1) You can take a tablet with you to the crapper. True, some people have been using smartphones and even laptops in there, but a tablet has the proper in-between form factor. 2) A tablet can offload some activity from PCs, keeping them fresher and snappier. PCs "wear out" for both hardware and software reasons, such as HD fragmentation, garbage files and services, malware, etc.
-
(again, disclaimer, I don't own a tablet, I have not yet found the use for it; but it's getting there) The tablet form factor is a lot more "performant" when the user does not have access to a desk; most people do not "create" content on tablets; they consume it. In the case of medical professional, they will just the tablet as a read-only device with limited annotation features, they will read the patient's dossier, watch xrays/mri, look up drugs dependencies and make small annotations here and there; and when they want to actively "write" stuff, they'll go back to their office, dock the tablet and use a real keyboard. As for customization, the normal people (99.99%) don't care about it, they want a computer/laptop/tablet/phone that just works for a normal number of months/years.
Nihil obstat
I think you pretty much said it all. Tablets do have a use for information retrieval with minimal typing - basically a PIMP (Personal Information Manager Processor). I could also see my wife using one for playing games (but she won't go near a desktop or laptop) - she got hooked on a some handheld games - Freecell, Solitaire, Yahtzee (always find it in the bathroom - so now we take a "Yahtzee"). As far as doing useful work, I can see they are limited compared to a decent size screen and keyboard. With USB sticks and SSDs increasing in memory capacity, plus "instant startup", netbooks and small laptops will not go away. If you consider packing a netbook (and a small mouse) in a brief case or suit case vs a separate keyboard - "chiclet"(?), your tablet, a bottle of Windex, etc., it becomes more convenient to take a single unit with a 64GB or 128GB SSD to take notes and enter data than a tablet. I don't own a tablet either (maybe in a couple of weeks, I'll get an old Android from my younger daughter when we go to visit her and her husband - I always seem to get my kids "hand-me-downs").
-
When I took my current job with the school district I work for, I knew I needed something more portable than the laptop they gave me. As a campus technician, I'm responsible for maintaining all of the technology on at least five different campuses and troubleshooting any issues they run into. Occasionally I also work on other projects like site surveys for upcoming technology installs. My tablet has seriously exploded the level of productivity I'm capable of in all of these areas. I got an ASUS Transformer TF300T with a Tegra 3 quad core processor, 1GB of RAM and 32GB of internal storage. It's currently running Android 4.1.1. I did not get the optional detachable keyboard but, as I found out, I really don't need it. The on-screen keyboard is a lot more usable than I thought it would be. So what have I used it for? The digital classroom project involves installed an audio system in the drop ceiling, an interactive HD projector on the wall above the dry-erase board, electrical conduit and receptacles, and a number of connections below the board for various other pieces of technology. The site survey for this required pictures of the room, the board, and the space above the ceiling from several angles, measurements, and detailed notes for every classroom it went into. At the end of each survey, the pictures and the notes needed to be put into a report with a specific format, meaning a word document with a table that had a column for room numbers, one for pictures, and one for notes broken into a bullet point list. Instead of lugging around a laptop, a camera, and a tape measure, all I used were the tablet and the tape measure. I created the report on the tablet, took the pictures with the tablet and had them automatically placed in the right place in the report, and typed up my notes and measurements right there. No arm strain, no worry of running out of battery, no extraneous baggage or bulk. I would then upload the entire report from my tablet into our web-based file system where everyone could access it. When I'm working my tickets, I log into the ticketing system from my tablet, access stored documents on a shared drive on my laptop which I set up in a central location and leave there as I go about my business, keep track of appointments using a widget on my home screen that syncs with my outlook calendar, reset passwords and manage Active Directory user and computer accounts with ActiveDir Manager, generate network maps for subnets I'm troubleshooting devices on and ping or tracero
+5 thanks for an excellent hands-on review, and usage example. best, Bill
~ Confused by Windows 8 ? This may help: [^] !