Preferred Pedagogical Paradigmatic Protocol
-
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people... 1. Binary Arithmetic 2. Boolean Algebra 3. Hexadecimal Arithmetic ...In what order would you present the concepts ? (That list is in alphabetical order to prevent any implied bias) Why do you feel that your chosen sequence makes more sense than others ?
-
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people... 1. Binary Arithmetic 2. Boolean Algebra 3. Hexadecimal Arithmetic ...In what order would you present the concepts ? (That list is in alphabetical order to prevent any implied bias) Why do you feel that your chosen sequence makes more sense than others ?
Boolean algebra is probably the easiest for people to grasp, as you can use real world examples:
IF it_is_raining
WEAR waterproof
ELSE
WEAR t-shirt
ENDIFBinary and HEX (or any other base) are especially challenging for people whose mathematical abilies may not be very high. I tried to explain both of those to someone once but they just could not get it.
-
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people... 1. Binary Arithmetic 2. Boolean Algebra 3. Hexadecimal Arithmetic ...In what order would you present the concepts ? (That list is in alphabetical order to prevent any implied bias) Why do you feel that your chosen sequence makes more sense than others ?
Base-12 -- with eggs. 12 eggs to a box, 12 boxes to a case... Just don't grind them up.
-
Boolean algebra is probably the easiest for people to grasp, as you can use real world examples:
IF it_is_raining
WEAR waterproof
ELSE
WEAR t-shirt
ENDIFBinary and HEX (or any other base) are especially challenging for people whose mathematical abilies may not be very high. I tried to explain both of those to someone once but they just could not get it.
I hesitate to post a non-KSS counter-argument to your example.
-
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people... 1. Binary Arithmetic 2. Boolean Algebra 3. Hexadecimal Arithmetic ...In what order would you present the concepts ? (That list is in alphabetical order to prevent any implied bias) Why do you feel that your chosen sequence makes more sense than others ?
The order in which they came historically. That would be the preferred logical order, i believe. Will give an opportunity to provide a logical motivation to the next topic.
-
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people... 1. Binary Arithmetic 2. Boolean Algebra 3. Hexadecimal Arithmetic ...In what order would you present the concepts ? (That list is in alphabetical order to prevent any implied bias) Why do you feel that your chosen sequence makes more sense than others ?
Charles Petzold explains these in his fantastic book, Code: The Hidden Language of Computers[^] (now, 2nd updated edition) Here's a helpful -- and free -- resource from the book --[^] really cool interactive code. 1. He explains Binary first using : 1 if by sea, 2 if by land. (Yes, he explains that the absence of any lantern (off) would normally indicate a value but since no-light could happen in normal circumstances you have to use 2 lanterns). He explains the entire on/off concept very clearly. 2. He then introduces George Bool and Boolean algebra 3. Then later he teaches Hex math. I think his system of building on basics works very well. if you haven't read his amazing book, I highly suggest it. Great concepts explained simply.
-
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people... 1. Binary Arithmetic 2. Boolean Algebra 3. Hexadecimal Arithmetic ...In what order would you present the concepts ? (That list is in alphabetical order to prevent any implied bias) Why do you feel that your chosen sequence makes more sense than others ?
Start with decimal notation using fully positional notation as opposed to something like Roman numerals which uses different symbols for powers of 10 but also has some positional rules. Give examples of arithmetic rules. Then drop to octal, since it's easier to understand using less symbols - counting with just your fingers and not using the thumbs. More arithmetic examples. Play around with a few other bases - duodecimal (base-12) or sexagesimal (base-60 - hours, minutes, seconds) - finally arriving at hexadecimal. More arithmetic... Maybe show base-4 or move straight to binary. Show the same arithmetic rules apply even when there's only 2 symbols. Show that any number in binary representation can be easily rewritten as hexadecimal or octal (and vice-versa) just by grouping/expanding the digits. Mention that, in computing, the term bit is a contraction of binary digit. Introduce Boolean algebra as a separate topic using English-like examples for AND, OR and NOT. Somewhere along the way, introduce De Morgan's Law - "NOT (A OR B)" gives the same results as "(NOT A) AND (NOT B)" Finally, show that if TRUE is one and FALSE is zero, then AND is the same as multiplying in binary and only looking at the last digit and OR is addition. You can then introduce logic gates and show how to build an adder circuit for 2 single bit numbers with a 2-bit output - least significant bit is OR, most significant/carry is AND but it can all be done with just AND/NOT or OR/NOT, so you only need one 2-input gate and an inverter (NOT). Etc.
-
Charles Petzold explains these in his fantastic book, Code: The Hidden Language of Computers[^] (now, 2nd updated edition) Here's a helpful -- and free -- resource from the book --[^] really cool interactive code. 1. He explains Binary first using : 1 if by sea, 2 if by land. (Yes, he explains that the absence of any lantern (off) would normally indicate a value but since no-light could happen in normal circumstances you have to use 2 lanterns). He explains the entire on/off concept very clearly. 2. He then introduces George Bool and Boolean algebra 3. Then later he teaches Hex math. I think his system of building on basics works very well. if you haven't read his amazing book, I highly suggest it. Great concepts explained simply.
+5 for Petzold. Great book. Also his Annotated Turing.
-
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people... 1. Binary Arithmetic 2. Boolean Algebra 3. Hexadecimal Arithmetic ...In what order would you present the concepts ? (That list is in alphabetical order to prevent any implied bias) Why do you feel that your chosen sequence makes more sense than others ?
C-P-User-3 wrote:
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people...
Then my goal would be to find a different goal because that isn't going to work. Certainly I have seen programmers that can't figure even one of those out. I would not want to try with a group of specialized university mathematics professors. Perhaps university mathematics students since then still have generalized concepts in their head. But only the ones doing well in their class work.
C-P-User-3 wrote:
Boolean Algebra
Not sure about the other two but I remember that this was an entire university semester long class that I took.
-
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people... 1. Binary Arithmetic 2. Boolean Algebra 3. Hexadecimal Arithmetic ...In what order would you present the concepts ? (That list is in alphabetical order to prevent any implied bias) Why do you feel that your chosen sequence makes more sense than others ?
I'd say binary first, since I recall teaching someone for their high school class ... after I had been out only a few years myself. (I was already programming by that time though I don't recall learning binary in HS). Of course, you ground them first with decimal, and how it relates. (With a side trip to Octal)
"Before entering on an understanding, I have meditated for a long time, and have foreseen what might happen. It is not genius which reveals to me suddenly, secretly, what I have to say or to do in a circumstance unexpected by other people; it is reflection, it is meditation." - Napoleon I
-
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people... 1. Binary Arithmetic 2. Boolean Algebra 3. Hexadecimal Arithmetic ...In what order would you present the concepts ? (That list is in alphabetical order to prevent any implied bias) Why do you feel that your chosen sequence makes more sense than others ?
Arithmetics: Binary and Hex and this and that base is all the same. Only the base is different. E.g. adding two numbers based on 2 or 16 or 10 following the same scheme. Boolean Algebra: This is a different from the above and needs to be explained seperately. Here the operators are different. Operators like 'logical and', 'logical or', 'not', .... that are boolean operations and not arithmetic operators. Why it is different Let us have two boolean variables 'a' and 'b'. They can only have the values TRUE or FALSE. One fundamental law in Boolean algebra is: a AND b == NOT(NOT a OR NOT b) which is very different from arithmetics I think. Same is valid for e.g. a OR b == NOT(NOT a AND NOT b)
*1) 'Arithmetic' example, more number representing for different bases
I assume you know all these, therefore only as a basic idea how to start....
In my opinion you need to explain what number representation based on a different bases means.
The very basic thing how to represent a number based on any base 'b' is:... b^2 b^1 b^0 ... b^-1 b^-2 ....
The available digits depend on the base.
Examples for bases and available digits:
Base 2 (binary) : 0, 1
Base 10 (decimal): 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9
Base 16 (Hex) : 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, A, B, C, D, E, FExample for the representataion of the decimal number 123 with different bases:
b^7 b^6 b^5 b^4 b^3 b^2 b^1 b^0
Base 2 : 128 64 32 16 8 4 2 1
0 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 = 1x64 + 1x32 + 1x16 + 1x8 + 1x2 + 1x1 = 123Base 10: 10^7 10^6 10^5 10^4 10^3 100 10 1
0 0 0 0 0 1 2 3 = 1x100 + 2x10 + 3x1 = 123Base 16: 16^7 16^6 16^5 16^4 16^3 16^2 16 1
0 0 0 0 0 0 7 B = 7x16 + Bx1= 123I hope I made no mistakes while writing the above ;)
-
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people... 1. Binary Arithmetic 2. Boolean Algebra 3. Hexadecimal Arithmetic ...In what order would you present the concepts ? (That list is in alphabetical order to prevent any implied bias) Why do you feel that your chosen sequence makes more sense than others ?
C-P-User-3 wrote:
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people...
Getting those concepts into the minds of a large group of people??, not gonna happen. You would rather forget about the order but think about the disorder you will cause.
"Coming soon"
-
Base-12 -- with eggs. 12 eggs to a box, 12 boxes to a case... Just don't grind them up.
That's just gross.
"One man's wage rise is another man's price increase." - Harold Wilson
"Fireproof doesn't mean the fire will never come. It means when the fire comes that you will be able to withstand it." - Michael Simmons
"You can easily judge the character of a man by how he treats those who can do nothing for him." - James D. Miles
-
Boolean algebra is probably the easiest for people to grasp, as you can use real world examples:
IF it_is_raining
WEAR waterproof
ELSE
WEAR t-shirt
ENDIFBinary and HEX (or any other base) are especially challenging for people whose mathematical abilies may not be very high. I tried to explain both of those to someone once but they just could not get it.
-
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people... 1. Binary Arithmetic 2. Boolean Algebra 3. Hexadecimal Arithmetic ...In what order would you present the concepts ? (That list is in alphabetical order to prevent any implied bias) Why do you feel that your chosen sequence makes more sense than others ?
You have to provide adequate incentive, threaten grievous bodily harm to those who don't understand maybe? :laugh:
"the debugger doesn't tell me anything because this code compiles just fine" - random QA comment "Facebook is where you tell lies to your friends. Twitter is where you tell the truth to strangers." - chriselst "I don't drink any more... then again, I don't drink any less." - Mike Mullikins uncle
-
If your goal is to get the following three concepts into the minds of a large group of people... 1. Binary Arithmetic 2. Boolean Algebra 3. Hexadecimal Arithmetic ...In what order would you present the concepts ? (That list is in alphabetical order to prevent any implied bias) Why do you feel that your chosen sequence makes more sense than others ?
You'd have more luck getting them to recite that rhyme straight ten times. On a slightly more serious note, hex is just binary, 4 bits at a time. Maybe mention octal as a stepping stone.
Software rusts. Simon Stephenson, ca 1994. So does this signature. me, 2012
-
Read up on number theory
In a closed society where everybody's guilty, the only crime is getting caught. In a world of thieves, the only final sin is stupidity. - Hunter S Thompson - RIP
-
Read up on number theory
In a closed society where everybody's guilty, the only crime is getting caught. In a world of thieves, the only final sin is stupidity. - Hunter S Thompson - RIP
-
I doubt that is useful. "Number theory", at best, covers quite a bit more than what was actually asked for. So attempting to answer the original question with that is not a good idea.
