So I'm a little late to the party :)
-
Just so you know, 128k is CD Quality, so you won't hear any degredation on that either. And you just mgiht be able to squeeze a few more songs on that CD.
"C++ : Where friends have access to your private members." — Gavin Russell Baker.
You're comparing apples to oranges. CD quality audio is PCM audio sampled at 44.1Hz a second using 16 bits per sample on two channels for stereo sound. What you're talking about is a compression sample rate for MP3s and WMAs and not what you actually hear. What you hear is the result of the compression's sample rate. Jeremy Falcon
-
I'm using Dolby Digital 5.1 in my truck and I honestly can't hear any difference. Maybe I'm going deaf :~
"C++ : Where friends have access to your private members." — Gavin Russell Baker.
Befriend a musician; they'll let you know. ;) Jeremy Falcon
-
Isn't 192Khz sampling a bit overkill? CD's already have a 44Khz sample rate which gives them a 0-22Khz frequency response. (Remember Nyquist?). Besides, you probably can't hear anything about 20Khz! Marc Latest AAL Article My blog Join my forum!
Marc Clifton wrote: Isn't 192Khz sampling a bit overkill? Nope! :) Jeremy Falcon
-
Marc Clifton wrote: Isn't 192Khz sampling a bit overkill? maybe it's 192bps, the minimum for a good quality with lossy algorithm
or maybe it's 192kbps :)
-
Just so you know, 128k is CD Quality, so you won't hear any degredation on that either. And you just mgiht be able to squeeze a few more songs on that CD.
"C++ : Where friends have access to your private members." — Gavin Russell Baker.
On MP3 at 128k, I tend to find that some material acquires a distinct 'phase' on it. Encode Lenny Kravitz' 'Are You Gonna Go My Way', which has a lot of crash cymbals in it, to 128kbps MP3 and play it back. The cymbals will sound very odd (unless encoders have got a lot better recently...). I think I had to go up to 256kbps to get an acceptable result. ISTR that the same track is perfectly acceptable in 96kbps WMA 9 - but this might vary for other tracks.
-
I'm using Dolby Digital 5.1 in my truck and I honestly can't hear any difference. Maybe I'm going deaf :~
"C++ : Where friends have access to your private members." — Gavin Russell Baker.
I'm with you. 128 kbps may not be as good as 160 or 192, but I can't hear the difference, and I certainly appreciate the smaller file size. :-) Regards, Alvaro
Hey! It compiles! Ship it.
-
Rob Manderson wrote: You don't even want to know what went onto the other cd :-) I'm using my iPAQ as a WMA player, and I was able to stick almost all of Queen's Greatest Hits I and II onto a 64 Meg SD card :-D. What was really surprising was that Media Player picks up the SD card on the iPAQ (connected via ActiveSync over 802.11) as a device in the "Copy to Devices" tab. I was actually impressed :-). -- Ian Darling "The moral of the story is that with a contrived example, you can prove anything." - Joel Spolsky
WMA? :shudder: I use my Toshiba+SD card as my mp3 player too. Ian Darling wrote: Media Player picks up the SD card on the iPAQ (connected via ActiveSync over 802.11) as a device in the "Copy to Devices" tab. I was actually impressed That's cool.... well.. learnt my one thing for the day :packs off and goes home: :-D The kindest thing you can do for a stupid person, and for the gene pool, is to let him expire of his own dumb choices. [Roger Wright on stupid people]
-
WMA? :shudder: I use my Toshiba+SD card as my mp3 player too. Ian Darling wrote: Media Player picks up the SD card on the iPAQ (connected via ActiveSync over 802.11) as a device in the "Copy to Devices" tab. I was actually impressed That's cool.... well.. learnt my one thing for the day :packs off and goes home: :-D The kindest thing you can do for a stupid person, and for the gene pool, is to let him expire of his own dumb choices. [Roger Wright on stupid people]
Atlantys wrote: WMA? :shudder: Well, Media Player on the Pocket PC doesn't pause when using MP3s :mad:, but it does with WMA. I don't really have a problem with encoding my own CDs as WMA for that specific purpose, and with the copy thing from the desktop it's a bit more convenient anyway. -- Ian Darling "The moral of the story is that with a contrived example, you can prove anything." - Joel Spolsky
-
Isn't 192Khz sampling a bit overkill? CD's already have a 44Khz sample rate which gives them a 0-22Khz frequency response. (Remember Nyquist?). Besides, you probably can't hear anything about 20Khz! Marc Latest AAL Article My blog Join my forum!
Marc Clifton wrote: you probably can't hear anything about 20Khz! At my age I can't even hear 15 KHz (haven't been able to for years). Rob Manderson http://www.mindprobes.net You have an eight-ball and Tommy wants to buy two grams. You bought the eight-ball with a quarter-bag of grass, two reds, a six-pack of Old Milwaukie, and $4 in change. You want a profit margin of 35%. How much hash should you get from Tommy for your blow? - Roger Wright
-
Atlantys wrote: WMA? :shudder: Well, Media Player on the Pocket PC doesn't pause when using MP3s :mad:, but it does with WMA. I don't really have a problem with encoding my own CDs as WMA for that specific purpose, and with the copy thing from the desktop it's a bit more convenient anyway. -- Ian Darling "The moral of the story is that with a contrived example, you can prove anything." - Joel Spolsky
Ian Darling wrote: Media Player on the Pocket PC Or, you can be the Uber-Geek and write your own MP3 player for your PDA.. :-O:-O:-O Ian Darling wrote: doesn't pause I assume you meant "does pause", indicating that you don't like how MP3s work on the PPC, and that WMA files don't pause, which is why they are better.... unless I missed the boat on this one? :confused: The kindest thing you can do for a stupid person, and for the gene pool, is to let him expire of his own dumb choices. [Roger Wright on stupid people]
-
Ian Darling wrote: Media Player on the Pocket PC Or, you can be the Uber-Geek and write your own MP3 player for your PDA.. :-O:-O:-O Ian Darling wrote: doesn't pause I assume you meant "does pause", indicating that you don't like how MP3s work on the PPC, and that WMA files don't pause, which is why they are better.... unless I missed the boat on this one? :confused: The kindest thing you can do for a stupid person, and for the gene pool, is to let him expire of his own dumb choices. [Roger Wright on stupid people]
No, I meant just that. Media Player on the Pocket PC doesn't pause MP3s (it effectively behaves as Stop), but does pause WMAs properly. Normally I'd prefer MP3s (being a more open standard), but I don't have a problem with WMA if I'm encoding from another form of media I already have available (like CD) -- Ian Darling "The moral of the story is that with a contrived example, you can prove anything." - Joel Spolsky