Step by step walkthrough
-
Hi all Are the step by step walk-through's actually articles? An article should, IMHO, discuss in a detail a technique and reasons of that approach, put in evidence pros and cons, analyze different situations. Lately I'm seeing a bunch of new articles that have two
couple ofword's per picture, on a banal arguments, and I just will not click on approve! What's yours on this? Cheers -
Hi all Are the step by step walk-through's actually articles? An article should, IMHO, discuss in a detail a technique and reasons of that approach, put in evidence pros and cons, analyze different situations. Lately I'm seeing a bunch of new articles that have two
couple ofword's per picture, on a banal arguments, and I just will not click on approve! What's yours on this? CheersI would agree - I tend to post them as Tip/Tricks instead myself.
Real men don't use instructions. They are only the manufacturers opinion on how to put the thing together. Manfred R. Bihy: "Looks as if OP is learning resistant."
-
Hi all Are the step by step walk-through's actually articles? An article should, IMHO, discuss in a detail a technique and reasons of that approach, put in evidence pros and cons, analyze different situations. Lately I'm seeing a bunch of new articles that have two
couple ofword's per picture, on a banal arguments, and I just will not click on approve! What's yours on this? CheersUnfortunately, most people that are looking for the this type of information (How do I..) aren’t interested as to why a particular method works or the potential pitfalls of using the method, they just want to implement a method because someone told them they should do it that way and they’re unable to say Uh I don’t know how…. Or It could be someone like myself who likes a little of the background but don’t want to spend a ton of time reading and researching the ins and outs of a particular method. I may just need to implement a unknown (or unfamiliar) method and getting some example code and steps on implementation is very helpful. They would be good for tips and tricks as long as it isn't too involved. Other wise yeah I supposed it could be an article if it takes more than a few paragraphs to step through. But you're right, they tend to be more instructions on how to. Maybe CP could have a "How To" section?
It was broke, so I fixed it.
-
Unfortunately, most people that are looking for the this type of information (How do I..) aren’t interested as to why a particular method works or the potential pitfalls of using the method, they just want to implement a method because someone told them they should do it that way and they’re unable to say Uh I don’t know how…. Or It could be someone like myself who likes a little of the background but don’t want to spend a ton of time reading and researching the ins and outs of a particular method. I may just need to implement a unknown (or unfamiliar) method and getting some example code and steps on implementation is very helpful. They would be good for tips and tricks as long as it isn't too involved. Other wise yeah I supposed it could be an article if it takes more than a few paragraphs to step through. But you're right, they tend to be more instructions on how to. Maybe CP could have a "How To" section?
It was broke, so I fixed it.
That also crossed my mind. We have many "new" sections, as tech blogs, videos, tips, etc. Should we suggest finding space for a new category?
-
Hi all Are the step by step walk-through's actually articles? An article should, IMHO, discuss in a detail a technique and reasons of that approach, put in evidence pros and cons, analyze different situations. Lately I'm seeing a bunch of new articles that have two
couple ofword's per picture, on a banal arguments, and I just will not click on approve! What's yours on this? CheersI'd say that's a bit of a gray area... although two words per picture is a bit extreme :wtf:
-
Hi all Are the step by step walk-through's actually articles? An article should, IMHO, discuss in a detail a technique and reasons of that approach, put in evidence pros and cons, analyze different situations. Lately I'm seeing a bunch of new articles that have two
couple ofword's per picture, on a banal arguments, and I just will not click on approve! What's yours on this? CheersIt depends what the step by step is setting out to achieve. I recently wrote an article that held the developers hand while they created a Windows Phone application. The key thing with it was not detailing how to create the application - that was a by product - but to have a detailed explanation of what code was produced, and what it does. So yes, walk-throughs can be articles, if they end up teaching something.
Forgive your enemies - it messes with their heads
"Mind bleach! Send me mind bleach!" - Nagy Vilmos
My blog | My articles | MoXAML PowerToys | Mole 2010 - debugging made easier - my favourite utility
-
I'd say that's a bit of a gray area... although two words per picture is a bit extreme :wtf:
Damn Italian! We are use to say due parole (two words) in the situations like Vorrei spendere due parole su questa traduzione = I would like to say a few words about this translation Because of that, sometimes, I just forget that, that not everything can be just simply translated! ;)
-
It depends what the step by step is setting out to achieve. I recently wrote an article that held the developers hand while they created a Windows Phone application. The key thing with it was not detailing how to create the application - that was a by product - but to have a detailed explanation of what code was produced, and what it does. So yes, walk-throughs can be articles, if they end up teaching something.
Forgive your enemies - it messes with their heads
"Mind bleach! Send me mind bleach!" - Nagy Vilmos
My blog | My articles | MoXAML PowerToys | Mole 2010 - debugging made easier - my favourite utility
I peeled your article and I liked it. Intro, plain of explanations, discussing the background, describing the situations. However it is not at this type of articles that I'm referring. But on articles like this Learning jQuery using jQuery Lab[^] Cheers
-
Damn Italian! We are use to say due parole (two words) in the situations like Vorrei spendere due parole su questa traduzione = I would like to say a few words about this translation Because of that, sometimes, I just forget that, that not everything can be just simply translated! ;)
:laugh:
-
It depends what the step by step is setting out to achieve. I recently wrote an article that held the developers hand while they created a Windows Phone application. The key thing with it was not detailing how to create the application - that was a by product - but to have a detailed explanation of what code was produced, and what it does. So yes, walk-throughs can be articles, if they end up teaching something.
Forgive your enemies - it messes with their heads
"Mind bleach! Send me mind bleach!" - Nagy Vilmos
My blog | My articles | MoXAML PowerToys | Mole 2010 - debugging made easier - my favourite utility
I agree... :thumbsup:
-
:laugh:
What is the correct English form, a couple of words, a few words? What will suit this situation?
-
It depends what the step by step is setting out to achieve. I recently wrote an article that held the developers hand while they created a Windows Phone application. The key thing with it was not detailing how to create the application - that was a by product - but to have a detailed explanation of what code was produced, and what it does. So yes, walk-throughs can be articles, if they end up teaching something.
Forgive your enemies - it messes with their heads
"Mind bleach! Send me mind bleach!" - Nagy Vilmos
My blog | My articles | MoXAML PowerToys | Mole 2010 - debugging made easier - my favourite utility
Pete O'Hanlon wrote:
So yes, walk-throughs can be articles, if they end up teaching something.
Very good point! And your article was good as well, I did learn some good information from going through it. Maybe there should be a four word minimum on captions. and a banality ban! ;)
It was broke, so I fixed it.
-
What is the correct English form, a couple of words, a few words? What will suit this situation?
Yes, you can say, "I'd like to say a couple of words on this subject." It doesn't mean exactly two words in this situation. It is basically synonymous with "a few words". If you say "I'd like to say 2 words on this subject, people might expect 2 words. [I grew up in an Italian household here in the States. My grandparents and mother would continue to make errors like this, and I swear my construction of English is based on learning it from them, though they never grasped it to begin with!]
"I have a theory that the truth is never told during the nine-to-five hours. " — Hunter S. Thompson My comedy.
-
What is the correct English form, a couple of words, a few words? What will suit this situation?
A few words would be the proper term. "A couple" implies two, although many people don't realize this and use it freely to mean a few, but that's actually incorrect.
-
What is the correct English form, a couple of words, a few words? What will suit this situation?
Step 0: Do this. Step 1: Do that. Step 2: STOP THAT!
It was broke, so I fixed it.
-
Yes, you can say, "I'd like to say a couple of words on this subject." It doesn't mean exactly two words in this situation. It is basically synonymous with "a few words". If you say "I'd like to say 2 words on this subject, people might expect 2 words. [I grew up in an Italian household here in the States. My grandparents and mother would continue to make errors like this, and I swear my construction of English is based on learning it from them, though they never grasped it to begin with!]
"I have a theory that the truth is never told during the nine-to-five hours. " — Hunter S. Thompson My comedy.
"a couple" has actually been bastardized over time... it does literally mean two though... so I wouldn't recommend people to say that if that's not what they mean.
-
"a couple" has actually been bastardized over time... it does literally mean two though... so I wouldn't recommend people to say that if that's not what they mean.
Great to know! Check it now, freshly edited! :)
-
"a couple" has actually been bastardized over time... it does literally mean two though... so I wouldn't recommend people to say that if that's not what they mean.
the term "a couple of words" is almost a Colloquialism with its own meaning. I told him he can use it because nobody on this planet would expect him to say exactly two words if he started a sentence, "Let me add a couple of words on this matter" If he said, "Let me add 2 words on this matter" people might expect 2 words. Call it bastardization, but it's silly to fight what is commonly used and understood. Do we still speak the same English as Shakespeare on either side of the pond? [Actually, seeing his correction, it may still be unclear with "couple of" It is better to be specific, especially when written.]
"I have a theory that the truth is never told during the nine-to-five hours. " — Hunter S. Thompson My comedy.
-
Great to know! Check it now, freshly edited! :)
:laugh:
-
Great to know! Check it now, freshly edited! :)
Yeah, in this case, I'd go with "just a few words".
"I have a theory that the truth is never told during the nine-to-five hours. " — Hunter S. Thompson My comedy.
