What is missing in all football (soccer) rants...
-
What a load of rubbish. Soccer (or football, whatever you call it) has rules. Those who do not obey the rules are cheating. Simple. It makes no difference where you're from or what your life is like.
Diego Moita wrote:
their institutions work, their justice is most of times just.
Not sure where you got that from. It's simply not true.
Diego Moita wrote:
those who deserve do not always win and you can't trust in police and judges (or referees).
I hate to break it to you, but that's the same everywhere. I live in Australia, and it's exactly like that here. The point is that soccer is an international sport, and as such, it has rules that the players must abide by to ensure that everyone gets a fair go. Remember that there are many different countries competing, and you can't favour some over others. It has to be structured to ensure that it can be played fairly by everyone. Soccer is not an acting recital. The object of the game is to score goals to legitimately beat the opposition, not to see who can get the most free kicks by pretending they are injured. I think the players often forget that.
Ryan
"Punctuality is only a virtue for those who aren't smart enough to think of good excuses for being late" John Nichol "Point Of Impact"
Of course football has rules, but the fact that the referee is a human that can be mistaken sometimes, spices the game (among other factors). I can imagine the frustration Australian fans are feeling because the referee invented a penalty kick that didn't exist, and that mistake eliminated Australia from advancing to quarter finals. A polar bear is a bear whose coordinates has been changed in terms of sine and cosine.
-
Colin Angus Mackay wrote:
The sport is dull and the organisers know it because of the amount of eye candy in the form of pretty dancing girls
Not logical. NBA always had pretty dancing girls but still was not popular until recent years. The popularity of the "sport" of basketball has risen dramatically in the past 30 years. That is why the spectatorship has increased not because of the commercialization. PGA spectatorship has risen in the past decade due to the rise in popularity of the "sport" (if you can call it that) of Golf, they have no pretty dancing girls. I imagine most spectators of PGA events actually play golf, that's why they don't find it dull.
led mike wrote:
I imagine most spectators of PGA events actually play golf, that's why they don't find it dull.
I don't play rugby, but of all the sports that is the most exciting. I'm sorry, but back to American Football, if the programme says that the sport takes 60 minutes in 4 quarters, I expect to see a game and be out of the stadium in about 90 minutes. But there is a lot of stopping and starting and dragging out of everything. All in all there is probably only a few minutes of real excitement on the park. A good game of Rugby between two equally matched teams is wall to wall excitement for the full 80 minutes of game time. They have about 5 - 10 minutes of break in the middle and that is it. There is no need for pretty dancing girls. The pre-match entertainment is the massed pipe and drums of some army regiment. Even between mismatched teams it is exciting. I saw Scotland play South Africa who were the reigning world champions at the time and that was a great game. I had no illusions that Scotland were ever going to win the game, but I paid my ticket to see my team lose because I knew it would be exciting.
Scottish Developers events: * .NET debugging, tracing and instrumentation by Duncan Edwards Jones and Code Coverage in .NET by Craig Murphy * Developer Day Scotland: are you interested in speaking or attending? My: Website | Blog
-
Of course football has rules, but the fact that the referee is a human that can be mistaken sometimes, spices the game (among other factors). I can imagine the frustration Australian fans are feeling because the referee invented a penalty kick that didn't exist, and that mistake eliminated Australia from advancing to quarter finals. A polar bear is a bear whose coordinates has been changed in terms of sine and cosine.
Fernando A. Gómez F. wrote:
but the fact that the referee is a human that can be mistaken sometimes, spices the game (among other factors).
Possibly, but that's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about the blatant acting the players undertake simply to get a free kick and get an unfair advantage.
Ryan
"Punctuality is only a virtue for those who aren't smart enough to think of good excuses for being late" John Nichol "Point Of Impact"
-
led mike wrote:
I imagine most spectators of PGA events actually play golf, that's why they don't find it dull.
I don't play rugby, but of all the sports that is the most exciting. I'm sorry, but back to American Football, if the programme says that the sport takes 60 minutes in 4 quarters, I expect to see a game and be out of the stadium in about 90 minutes. But there is a lot of stopping and starting and dragging out of everything. All in all there is probably only a few minutes of real excitement on the park. A good game of Rugby between two equally matched teams is wall to wall excitement for the full 80 minutes of game time. They have about 5 - 10 minutes of break in the middle and that is it. There is no need for pretty dancing girls. The pre-match entertainment is the massed pipe and drums of some army regiment. Even between mismatched teams it is exciting. I saw Scotland play South Africa who were the reigning world champions at the time and that was a great game. I had no illusions that Scotland were ever going to win the game, but I paid my ticket to see my team lose because I knew it would be exciting.
Scottish Developers events: * .NET debugging, tracing and instrumentation by Duncan Edwards Jones and Code Coverage in .NET by Craig Murphy * Developer Day Scotland: are you interested in speaking or attending? My: Website | Blog
Colin Angus Mackay wrote:
I don't play rugby, but of all the sports that is the most exciting.
What little I've seen of it I can tell that it probably is exciting but since I don't understand it it becomes dull very soon.
Colin Angus Mackay wrote:
But there is a lot of stopping and starting and dragging out of everything.
The stopping and starting is part of the nature of the game. If you played a football game say in High school or college it seems very fast paced. The 30 seconds between plays goes by very fast. The dragging out is an artifact of the NFL and the commercialized aspects. See a NCAA football game and it won't be dragged out.
"Just about every question you've asked over the last 3-4 days has been "urgent". Perhaps a little planning would be helpful?"
Colin Angus Mackay in the C# forumled mike
-
Colin Angus Mackay wrote:
I don't play rugby, but of all the sports that is the most exciting.
What little I've seen of it I can tell that it probably is exciting but since I don't understand it it becomes dull very soon.
Colin Angus Mackay wrote:
But there is a lot of stopping and starting and dragging out of everything.
The stopping and starting is part of the nature of the game. If you played a football game say in High school or college it seems very fast paced. The 30 seconds between plays goes by very fast. The dragging out is an artifact of the NFL and the commercialized aspects. See a NCAA football game and it won't be dragged out.
"Just about every question you've asked over the last 3-4 days has been "urgent". Perhaps a little planning would be helpful?"
Colin Angus Mackay in the C# forumled mike
led mike wrote:
since I don't understand it it becomes dull very soon.
I don't think that is a reason for it to be dull. I don't understand snooker (I can barely play pool) yet on the odd occasion that I've watched it I found it to be interesting.
led mike wrote:
The dragging out is an artifact of the NFL and the commercialized aspects. See a NCAA football game and it won't be dragged out.
Perhaps I need to do that.
Scottish Developers events: * .NET debugging, tracing and instrumentation by Duncan Edwards Jones and Code Coverage in .NET by Craig Murphy * Developer Day Scotland: are you interested in speaking or attending? My: Website | Blog
-
led mike wrote:
since I don't understand it it becomes dull very soon.
I don't think that is a reason for it to be dull. I don't understand snooker (I can barely play pool) yet on the odd occasion that I've watched it I found it to be interesting.
led mike wrote:
The dragging out is an artifact of the NFL and the commercialized aspects. See a NCAA football game and it won't be dragged out.
Perhaps I need to do that.
Scottish Developers events: * .NET debugging, tracing and instrumentation by Duncan Edwards Jones and Code Coverage in .NET by Craig Murphy * Developer Day Scotland: are you interested in speaking or attending? My: Website | Blog
Colin Angus Mackay wrote:
I don't understand snooker (I can barely play pool) yet on the odd occasion that I've watched it I found it to be interesting.
Ok but snooker does not compare with Rugby. I mean it doesn't take much to understand Tennis right? But Rugby with the announcers using words I don't even know the meaning of... I couldn't get it at all. :doh:
"Just about every question you've asked over the last 3-4 days has been "urgent". Perhaps a little planning would be helpful?"
Colin Angus Mackay in the C# forumled mike
-
Colin Angus Mackay wrote:
I don't understand snooker (I can barely play pool) yet on the odd occasion that I've watched it I found it to be interesting.
Ok but snooker does not compare with Rugby. I mean it doesn't take much to understand Tennis right? But Rugby with the announcers using words I don't even know the meaning of... I couldn't get it at all. :doh:
"Just about every question you've asked over the last 3-4 days has been "urgent". Perhaps a little planning would be helpful?"
Colin Angus Mackay in the C# forumled mike
led mike wrote:
Ok but snooker does not compare with Rugby. I mean it doesn't take much to understand Tennis right?
It doesn't take much to understand Rugby either. It is somewhat similar to American Football except the players don't wear all that protective gear, a "touchdown" is a "try" a "conversion" is a PAT (but worth 2 points), there are 15 players who don't get swapped out depending on whether they are playing in an offensive or defensive position and the game doesn't stop and start all the time. There are two halves of 40 minutes each.
Scottish Developers events: * .NET debugging, tracing and instrumentation by Duncan Edwards Jones and Code Coverage in .NET by Craig Murphy * Developer Day Scotland: are you interested in speaking or attending? My: Website | Blog
-
led mike wrote:
Ok but snooker does not compare with Rugby. I mean it doesn't take much to understand Tennis right?
It doesn't take much to understand Rugby either. It is somewhat similar to American Football except the players don't wear all that protective gear, a "touchdown" is a "try" a "conversion" is a PAT (but worth 2 points), there are 15 players who don't get swapped out depending on whether they are playing in an offensive or defensive position and the game doesn't stop and start all the time. There are two halves of 40 minutes each.
Scottish Developers events: * .NET debugging, tracing and instrumentation by Duncan Edwards Jones and Code Coverage in .NET by Craig Murphy * Developer Day Scotland: are you interested in speaking or attending? My: Website | Blog
-
Colin Angus Mackay wrote:
the game doesn't stop and start all the time
Interesting... so how do the implement any sort of strategy?
led mike wrote:
so how do the implement any sort of strategy?
It isn't forbidden to speak during the game you know. They can decide on an overall strategy at the start and at half time but during the game the players actually talk to one another. Also, Rugby players tend to be very intelligent people - A few years ago the Scotland team captain was a medical doctor also.
Scottish Developers events: * .NET debugging, tracing and instrumentation by Duncan Edwards Jones and Code Coverage in .NET by Craig Murphy * Developer Day Scotland: are you interested in speaking or attending? My: Website | Blog
-
led mike wrote:
so how do the implement any sort of strategy?
It isn't forbidden to speak during the game you know. They can decide on an overall strategy at the start and at half time but during the game the players actually talk to one another. Also, Rugby players tend to be very intelligent people - A few years ago the Scotland team captain was a medical doctor also.
Scottish Developers events: * .NET debugging, tracing and instrumentation by Duncan Edwards Jones and Code Coverage in .NET by Craig Murphy * Developer Day Scotland: are you interested in speaking or attending? My: Website | Blog
Colin Angus Mackay wrote:
but during the game the players actually talk to one another.
Of course that is what the break is for in US football, to talk, call a play without the other team hearing what play you called, your whole team hears it, the other team does not. Seems reasonable to me, no?