PS3 or Wii ?
-
Any suggestions,the way its going xbox is leading sure but well cant seem to make up my mind.Or PS2 even?:confused:
I'd say a 360 is the best choice right now, with the Wii a close second (possibly taking the lead eventually). The PS3 is a nice system, but it doesn't have a large enough library to justify the overly large price. If you don't have a PS2 then get one. They're cheap, and even though it's not the newest system it has by far the largest library.
-
Well, dang. My post got swallowed. :doh: Here's a "quick" synopsis: Wii * Wider family friendly selection * Classic NES, SNES, N64 TurboGraphix 16 games on Virtual Console * Motion controls * Backwards compatable with GameCube games and peripherals (except GameBoy Adapter) * Doesn't support HDTV (pro or con, depending on your setup) * Doesn't play movies (that I know of) * No internal hard drive -- must use SD card to store settings, game saves, and Virtual Console games * Rumble controllers available (Wii-mote) * Online gaming not a priority with Nintendo PlayStation 3 * Less of a game selection for native games * 60gb and 80gb versions backwards compatable with PlayStation and PlayStation 2 games * Gyroscopic sensor in controller for motion controls (not as involving as Wii) * Plays a plethera of media types, including DVD and Blu-Ray video * Upscales PlayStation/PlayStation 2 games and DVD movies to HD * Doesn't works as well with standard definition TVs (SDTV) * Can install Linux on internal drive to use as a computer * Can link to computer through network for media serving * Rumble controllers not available until 2008 * Online games are free to play (some MMORPGs will have subscription fees -- none so far) * Hard drive upgradeable using standard SATA 2.5" notebook drives PlayStation 2 * Large selection of native games with more still being made * Peripherals (memory cards, controllers, etc.) are still being manufactured * Lowest cost of getting started * Backwards compatable with PlayStation games * Works with SDTV and HDTV setups * Supported games use 480p and even 1080i for sharper image (using component cables) * Rumble controllers available * Most games are free to play online (that support online play) Personally, I own the PlayStation, the PlayStation 2 and the 60 gb PlayStation 3 (upgraded to a 120 gb hard drive). I wouldn't mind getting a Wii (personally I think some of the games sound like a blast to play). The gyroscopic motion controls on the PS3 aren't as much fun as they could be, and the developers are still working out ways to add them in that don't feel gimmicky (Metal Gear Solid 4 sounds like it will have a more natural use for the motion controls). The backwards compatability with the older PS systems was my primary reason for getting the PS3, along with the ability to install Linux. :-> Flynn
Flynn Arrowstarr wrote:
Wii * Doesn't support HDTV (pro or con, depending on your setup) * No internal hard drive -- must use SD card to store settings, game saves, and Virtual Console games
a few corrections: *It does sort-of support HD. It'll do 480p and widescreen, which isn't true HD, but it's better than screen stretching or boxing. *It has 512MB of flash memory, which will hold a fair number of saves and VC games. You need a gamecube memory card to store gamecube saves though, which is a pain. *The VC also includes Sega Genisis games.
-
If you are more into games, Wii seems to have more, but the thing I like about the PS3 is you can play PS2 and PS2 games, and you can download a trial of new games to see if you want to invest in the game. Plus you have the BluRay player, play MP3s, show pics etc. It's really my husband's media center.
-
Flynn Arrowstarr wrote:
Wii * Doesn't support HDTV (pro or con, depending on your setup) * No internal hard drive -- must use SD card to store settings, game saves, and Virtual Console games
a few corrections: *It does sort-of support HD. It'll do 480p and widescreen, which isn't true HD, but it's better than screen stretching or boxing. *It has 512MB of flash memory, which will hold a fair number of saves and VC games. You need a gamecube memory card to store gamecube saves though, which is a pain. *The VC also includes Sega Genisis games.
Thanks. I thought it did 480p and widescreen, but wasn't sure. Err on the side of caution and all that, heh. The internal RAM is nice, but when you start getting in to the N64 games, those can get rather large. Having even a 10 gb hard drive would have been a better deal, in my opinion. :-D The PS2 will also do widescreen, though its implimentation leaves something to be desired (Final Fantasy 12's widescreen isn't that great for example). Running in widescreen without progressive scan is just... wrong. Flynn
-
Last week ...or the week before Sony annouced a future update to all versions of the PS3 dropping compatibility for the PS2.....This feature will disappear shortly.
Dewm Solo - Managed C++ Developer
Yes, and some are complaining while others aren't. I'm glad I got mine when I did, heh. They removed the EE chip (Emotion Engine) from the 80 gb model, though it supports PS2 through software emulation. With the new 40 gb model out next month, they will be removing the other chip (the GS chip, I think it's called) that will remove the software emulation as well -- which will effectively remove the PlayStation 1 emulation as well. Flynn
-
If you are more into games, Wii seems to have more, but the thing I like about the PS3 is you can play PS2 and PS2 games, and you can download a trial of new games to see if you want to invest in the game. Plus you have the BluRay player, play MP3s, show pics etc. It's really my husband's media center.
-
Hey honey :) While your husband is entertaining himself with his electronic toys maybe me and you could play a few games with eachother? ;) ;P
█▒▒▒▒▒██▒█▒██ █▒█████▒▒▒▒▒█ █▒██████▒█▒██ █▒█████▒▒▒▒▒█ █▒▒▒▒▒██▒█▒██
-
Hey honey :) While your husband is entertaining himself with his electronic toys maybe me and you could play a few games with eachother? ;) ;P
█▒▒▒▒▒██▒█▒██ █▒█████▒▒▒▒▒█ █▒██████▒█▒██ █▒█████▒▒▒▒▒█ █▒▒▒▒▒██▒█▒██
-
I'm too busy blogging. And no one has called me 'honey' since my mother.
-
Any suggestions,the way its going xbox is leading sure but well cant seem to make up my mind.Or PS2 even?:confused:
If you are a serious gamer then the Xbox 360 or PS3 with I'd say the PS3 being best in the coming two years as developers release some truly amazing games for it. Just like the Xbox 360 took awhile to be properly used when it was released. If you aren't a serious gamer then I'd get a Wii. They are going to release a Star Wars game for it with a lightsaber. That is going to ROCK. :-D I'd *like* a PS3 but I'd have at most 3 hours a week to play on it and frankly it isn't worth the money for that kind of use. A Wii is less than half the price and can be played for 15 minutes a night and you still have fun.
regards, Paul Watson Ireland & South Africa
Andy Brummer wrote:
Watson's law: As an online discussion of cars grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving the Bugatti Veyron approaches one.
-
I'd say a 360 is the best choice right now, with the Wii a close second (possibly taking the lead eventually). The PS3 is a nice system, but it doesn't have a large enough library to justify the overly large price. If you don't have a PS2 then get one. They're cheap, and even though it's not the newest system it has by far the largest library.
I don't know. There's a number of arguments for spending the cost of a PS3 other than game library. For instance, the 60 and 80 gb models have access to the exceptionally large PS2 library of games, plus you have the lowest cost of entry for a Blu-Ray player, a PPC 64-based Linux computer, upgradeable hardware and firmware, and a number of other things that make the cost more attractive. As much as we love the native PS3 games we have, we still buy a number of PS2 games and play many of the ones we currently have. There's even a number of the old PS1 role-playing games I play (Arc the Lad and Lunar in particular). So, yes the PS3 has fewer native games than the Xbox 360, but the backwards compatability opens the door to a ton more. :-> Flynn
-
If you are a serious gamer then the Xbox 360 or PS3 with I'd say the PS3 being best in the coming two years as developers release some truly amazing games for it. Just like the Xbox 360 took awhile to be properly used when it was released. If you aren't a serious gamer then I'd get a Wii. They are going to release a Star Wars game for it with a lightsaber. That is going to ROCK. :-D I'd *like* a PS3 but I'd have at most 3 hours a week to play on it and frankly it isn't worth the money for that kind of use. A Wii is less than half the price and can be played for 15 minutes a night and you still have fun.
regards, Paul Watson Ireland & South Africa
Andy Brummer wrote:
Watson's law: As an online discussion of cars grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving the Bugatti Veyron approaches one.
You may like the new 40 gb model coming out next month. Though, there are trade-offs -- you lose half the USB ports (two instead of four), backwards compatability, and the memory card reader. Unlike the original 20 gb model, this one does have the Wi-Fi. I think it's supposed to be $399 and will have Spider-Man 3 on Blu-Ray packed in the box (likely through the holidays -- then the movie pack-in goes away). The 80 gb model has dropped to $499 and the remaining 60 gb models are $449. Oh, and the slim PS2 is dropping to $99. :-> Flynn
If we can't corrupt the youth of today,
the adults of tomorrow will be no fun... -
You may like the new 40 gb model coming out next month. Though, there are trade-offs -- you lose half the USB ports (two instead of four), backwards compatability, and the memory card reader. Unlike the original 20 gb model, this one does have the Wi-Fi. I think it's supposed to be $399 and will have Spider-Man 3 on Blu-Ray packed in the box (likely through the holidays -- then the movie pack-in goes away). The 80 gb model has dropped to $499 and the remaining 60 gb models are $449. Oh, and the slim PS2 is dropping to $99. :-> Flynn
If we can't corrupt the youth of today,
the adults of tomorrow will be no fun...Still, €400 euro is a lot of money for a games machine. Still, I am glad they have a cheaper option that isn't crippled.
regards, Paul Watson Ireland & South Africa
Andy Brummer wrote:
Watson's law: As an online discussion of cars grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving the Bugatti Veyron approaches one.
-
Well, dang. My post got swallowed. :doh: Here's a "quick" synopsis: Wii * Wider family friendly selection * Classic NES, SNES, N64 TurboGraphix 16 games on Virtual Console * Motion controls * Backwards compatable with GameCube games and peripherals (except GameBoy Adapter) * Doesn't support HDTV (pro or con, depending on your setup) * Doesn't play movies (that I know of) * No internal hard drive -- must use SD card to store settings, game saves, and Virtual Console games * Rumble controllers available (Wii-mote) * Online gaming not a priority with Nintendo PlayStation 3 * Less of a game selection for native games * 60gb and 80gb versions backwards compatable with PlayStation and PlayStation 2 games * Gyroscopic sensor in controller for motion controls (not as involving as Wii) * Plays a plethera of media types, including DVD and Blu-Ray video * Upscales PlayStation/PlayStation 2 games and DVD movies to HD * Doesn't works as well with standard definition TVs (SDTV) * Can install Linux on internal drive to use as a computer * Can link to computer through network for media serving * Rumble controllers not available until 2008 * Online games are free to play (some MMORPGs will have subscription fees -- none so far) * Hard drive upgradeable using standard SATA 2.5" notebook drives PlayStation 2 * Large selection of native games with more still being made * Peripherals (memory cards, controllers, etc.) are still being manufactured * Lowest cost of getting started * Backwards compatable with PlayStation games * Works with SDTV and HDTV setups * Supported games use 480p and even 1080i for sharper image (using component cables) * Rumble controllers available * Most games are free to play online (that support online play) Personally, I own the PlayStation, the PlayStation 2 and the 60 gb PlayStation 3 (upgraded to a 120 gb hard drive). I wouldn't mind getting a Wii (personally I think some of the games sound like a blast to play). The gyroscopic motion controls on the PS3 aren't as much fun as they could be, and the developers are still working out ways to add them in that don't feel gimmicky (Metal Gear Solid 4 sounds like it will have a more natural use for the motion controls). The backwards compatability with the older PS systems was my primary reason for getting the PS3, along with the ability to install Linux. :-> Flynn
Flynn Arrowstarr wrote:
Doesn't works as well with standard definition TVs (SDTV)
Another correction - presuming you mean 'Doesn't work as well as the Wii with SDTV' - the PS3 is fine with SDTV - it just doesn't look as good as on HDTV. I've currently got my PS3 hooked up to an ancient CRT TV (pre-DVD!) and it is fine. Of course, when I upgrade to a nice HD screen, it'll be even better ;P!
-
Last week ...or the week before Sony annouced a future update to all versions of the PS3 dropping compatibility for the PS2.....This feature will disappear shortly.
Dewm Solo - Managed C++ Developer
Dewm Solo wrote:
This feature will disappear shortly.
Only from newly purchased PS3s, I think you'll find...
-
Any suggestions,the way its going xbox is leading sure but well cant seem to make up my mind.Or PS2 even?:confused:
-
Any suggestions,the way its going xbox is leading sure but well cant seem to make up my mind.Or PS2 even?:confused:
I have had a PS3 for 3 months now and am well happy with it. Games play well, high definition TV definetly adds more to games and bluray playback. Have had no hardware problems and setting it up with my wireless network was as easy as entering my WEP key. My only gripe has been the initial price of the games, but now they seem to be dropping to the £30-£40 price for new releases is not so bad.
-
Any suggestions,the way its going xbox is leading sure but well cant seem to make up my mind.Or PS2 even?:confused:
I would get a PS3. Wii is no competition for X360 and PS3 if you are a serious gamer. It's not even a next-gen console, if you compare it's capabilities it is somewhat similar to PS2 (graphics, processing power). It is a great TOY, the controllers are awesome and I would like to have one to play on some birthday parties and such, but if I had to choose only one console it would be X360 or PS3 (and this depends on available titles). I own a PS2 currently.
Kind regards, Pawel Krakowiak